Could RILAs, Pension Risk Transfers Squeeze Life Insurers in a Crisis?

News October 23, 2023 at 02:12 PM
Share & Print

State insurance regulators are thinking about whether some types of annuity separate accounts could affect life insurers' need for quick cash in an economic crisis.

The Macroprudential Working Group, part of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, mentions separate accounts associated with registered index-linked annuities and pension risk transfers in a new draft of the 2023 liquidity stress framework.

The final version of the framework will affect insurers' analysis of their need for cash and their access to cash, and how those might change during periods of economic stress.

What it means: Adding RILAs and pension risk transfers to liquidity stress testing could affect how regulators think about how insurers' cash-flow projections and about how others think about insurers' stability.

Regulators could also use any extra data about the effects of RILAs  and pension risk transfer transactions to address concerns of the Federal Reserve Board about life insurance company liquidity. The board suggested in a financial stability report posted Friday that insurers may be selling too many products that give customers too much ability to pull cash out quickly during a crisis.

The testing and thinking could affect how well the insurers back clients' life insurance policies and annuities during a market crash or other crisis.

The background: In the past, regulators have asked insurers to focus on the cash-flow impact of guaranteed benefits in liquidity stress testing, or LST, calculations, because of concerns about the impact of guaranteed benefits on liquidity stress.

Now, in the draft 2023 framework, officials have penciled in a reference both to RILAs and to pension risk transfers.

Officials posted the draft last week, and comments are due Nov. 15.

Definitions: A RILA is a variable annuity with the investment options based on the performance of investment indexes, such as the S&P 500, rather than on the performance of funds that resemble mutual funds.

RILA issuers may offer features such as caps on gains and buffers against losses, or floors limiting losses. Observers have noted that some of the features may introduce guarantee risk.

A pension risk transfer, or PRT, is a move to have a life insurer use a big group annuity to assume pension plan risk from the original pension plan sponsor.

The new language: Officials acknowledge in the draft that life insurers need not include information about separate accounts in 2023 liquidity stress testing.

"Separate accounts remain under review for further LST enhancements," officials note.

"Insurers are requested to provide total assets of separate account products backing general account products (e.g., PRT, RILA) that have a separate account guarantee," according to a proposed addition to the framework.

Any proposed language must be voted upon and approved by regulator member of the Macroprudential Working Group

Credit: Adobe Stock

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center