IRS Faces Uproar Over Draft Regulations for Client-Owned Insurers

News July 20, 2023 at 11:23 AM
Share & Print

State lawmakers, actuaries and others are trying to persuade the Internal Revenue Service to change draft regulations that could affect business-owner clients who use their own small insurance companies, or "micro captive" insurers, to manage risk.

The IRS held a teleconference hearing on the draft Wednesday. Four Treasury Department and IRS officials appeared, along with five micro captive advisors and the CEO of a bank that owns a micro captive.

IRS Concerns

Some business owners have set up micro captives based on section 831(b) of the Internal Revenue Code. For 2023, the micro captive annual premium size limit is $2.65 million.

The IRS sees many of the micro captives as efforts to reduce federal income taxes by turning what should be taxable income into premium payments for insurance against highly unlikely events, such as catastrophic earthquakes. The government taxes the captive's investment income but not its premium revenue.

The IRS proposed requiring a micro captive to spend at least 65% of its premiums on claims and to meet other standards. The agency noted that, in addition to requiring abusive micro captive owners to pay the taxes previously avoided, it might impose a 20% or 40% penalty.

The Objections

The American Academy of Actuaries told the IRS that the proposed 65% minimum loss ratio is based on unrealistic comparisons of micro captives and commercial insurers.

The National Council of Insurance Legislators said the IRS would be exceeding its authority if it tried to regulate insurance company loss ratios.

Van Carlson, the CEO of SRA 831(b), a Meridian, Idaho-based micro captive advisor, said in an email interview that, if implemented as written, the draft regulations "could have devastating effects on the entire alternative risk financing industry," by exposing honest micro captive users to the threat of frequent IRS audits.

Credit: ALM

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center