Debate: Do Taxpayers Benefit From New Hardship Distribution Rules?

Expert Opinion November 08, 2024 at 12:30 PM
Share & Print

Robert Bloink and William H. Byrnes

The Secure Act now allows penalty-free withdrawals to cover expenses related to the birth or adoption of a child.  The Secure 2.0 Act also contained many provisions that expanded taxpayers' ability to access retirement funds without penalty.

One new provision allows taxpayers to withdraw up to $2,500 each year to cover the costs of long-term care insurance without triggering a 10% early withdrawal penalty, starting in 2025.

Beginning in 2024, plan participants are entitled to take penalty-free withdrawals if they certify that they have been a victim of domestic violence by a spouse or domestic partner within the one-year period before the withdrawal.  

Taxpayers who have been certified by a physician as being terminally ill are also now permitted to take penalty-free withdrawals.

We asked two professors and authors of ALM's Tax Facts with opposing political viewpoints to share their opinions about expanding the hardship distribution rules to allow for penalty-free distributions for different reasons.

Below is a summary of the debate that ensued between the two professors.

Their Votes:

Bloink

Thumbs down Byrnes

Their Reasons:

Bloink: One of the primary reasons that Americans fail to take advantage of tax-preferred retirement savings options is the fear of needing the funds prior to retirement and incurring penalties on top of ordinary income tax rates for hardship withdrawals.

Expanding the limited list of reasons why a participant can access retirement funds without penalty is key to encouraging increased retirement savings.  

Byrnes: Expanding the hardship distribution rules only serves to encourage leakage from these retirement plans.  The early withdrawal penalties exist for a very good reason. 

If retirement accounts are simply treated as any other type of savings account, taxpayers are given a powerful tax break without the strong incentive to allow those funds to remain in the retirement account.

Bloink: The list of reasons for penalty-free retirement distributions is not endless — and participants are required to certify their legitimate need for the funds.  That provides built-in safeguards.  Further, distributions are never tax-free. 

We're only talking about allowing taxpayers to access their own hard-earned funds for legitimate hardship-based reasons.

Byrnes: Plans that allow hardship distributions may now rely on the employee's certification as to the existence of the hardship and the amount needed.  That essentially means that employees can access their tax-preferred retirement funds for any reason whatsoever. 

This is not how tax-preferred retirement accounts are meant to function.  

Bloink: Without these types of hardship expansions, lower-income taxpayers are much less likely to adequately save to fund retirement.  Essentially, this is a type of compromise. 

In the end, expanding the explicitly stated reasons for hardship distributions narrows the field and allows employers to provide clear limits on the reasons that penalty-free distributions will be permitted.

Byrnes: Pre-Secure Act, we already had a list of legitimate reasons for penalty-free withdrawals prior to retirement. 

Any expansion does more harm than good in that it gives participants legitimized reasons to drain their retirement savings — and retirement saving is something that we should be trying to increase, which is why the early withdrawal penalty taxes exist in the first place.

  • Learn more with Tax Facts, the go-to resource that answers critical tax questions with the latest tax developments. Online subscribers get access to exclusive e-newsletters.
  • Discover more resources on finance and taxes on the NU Resource Center.
  • Follow Tax Facts on LinkedIn and join the conversation on financial planning and targeted tax topics.
  • Get 10% off any Tax Facts product just for being a ThinkAdvisor reader! Complete the free trial form or call 859-692-2205 to learn more or get started today.
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center