Musk Wants $2T Cut From the Budget. It'd Be Difficult

Analysis October 28, 2024 at 03:48 PM
Share & Print

What You Need To Know

  • It would likely entail significant cuts to popular programs such as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and veterans' benefits.
  • Trump's first term showed just how elusive spending cuts can be.
  • Lawmakers are generally loathe to pass on pain to programs sending billions to their states and to voters.
Scissors cutting money

Elon Musk predicted he could cut at least $2 trillion from the U.S. federal budget, a lofty goal that would require a level of austerity unprecedented since the winding down of World War II.

His target, mentioned at Donald Trump's Sunday rally in Madison Square Garden, exceeds the amount Congress spends annually on government agency operations, including defense.

It would likely require making significant cuts to popular entitlement programs such as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and veterans' benefits.

In short, it's easier said than done — even for the world's richest man, who Trump has said he'd appoint to lead a government efficiency commission should he win a second term in the White House.

Last fiscal year, the government spent more than $6.75 trillion, with more than $5.3 trillion of that coming from Social Security, health care, defense and veterans' benefits — all of which are politically fraught and notoriously difficult to convince Congress to cut — as well as interest on the debt.

Musk's own companies — including Tesla Inc. and SpaceX — have billions of dollars worth of federal contracts and have benefited from government spending, including electric vehicle tax credits and infrastructure investments, further underscoring the difficulty of implementing a $2 trillion cut.

US Government Spending | Amount spent in fiscal 2024 across categories

Trump's first term showed just how elusive spending cuts can be. His efforts to slash spending on Affordable Care Act insurance subsidies failed in the Senate, and Congress rejected many of his other proposed spending cuts to domestic agencies.

Trump eventually agreed to major increases in discretionary spending followed by trillions in pandemic-era relief in a series of bipartisan deals that ballooned the deficit.

Trump has since said, however, that he would seek to shrink spending by impounding funding approved by Congress, challenging a 1974 law limiting the president's authority to withhold appropriated funds.

The closest to Musk's austerity push would be a budget proposed by Republican Senator Rand Paul, which would cut spending by 6% a year every year for five years, until the U.S. budget is balanced.

That blueprint, which doesn't specify which programs would be cut, was blocked on a 56-39 procedural vote in the Senate last month, opposed by Republican defense hawks like Roger Wicker, the top Republican on the Armed Services Committee, and Susan Collins, the top Republican on the powerful Appropriations Committee.

If Trump's impoundment gambit failed, he'd need Congress to back his cuts, and lawmakers are generally loathe to pass on pain to programs sending billions to their states and to voters.

In the Senate, it takes just a simple majority to cut mandatory federal spending programs other than Social Security. But it would typically take 60 votes to overcome the chamber's filibuster rule on annual spending bills, giving Democrats leverage to prevent major cuts.

Republican infighting over spending levels and policies have also forced GOP leaders to repeatedly seek Democratic votes to keep the government open and extend the federal debt limit, which will need to be raised again next year.

 (Adobe Stock)

Copyright 2024 Bloomberg. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Related Stories

Resource Center