U.S. Needs Bermuda to Boost Annuity Supply, Regulators Say

News October 15, 2024 at 10:57 AM
Share & Print

What You Need To Know

  • The world faced a $106 trillion retirement asset gap in 2022, Swiss Re estimates.
  • Speakers at a life and annuity conference in Bermuda emphasized the big capital hole left by years of low interest rates.
  • A top insurance regulator emphasized the need for both consumer protection and innovation.
Grotto Bay Beach Resort & Spa in Hamilton Parish, Bermuda, on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2020. Credit: Nicola Muirhead/Bloomberg

U.S. regulators are thinking about how Bermuda's reinsurance market can help create an adequate supply of life insurance policies and annuities as well as the need to maintain high safety standards.

Andrew Mais, the Connecticut insurance commissioner and National Association of Insurance Commissioners president, talked about the product supply problem recently at a life and annuity conference in Bermuda that was organized by Bermuda International Long Term Insurers and Reinsurers.

Mais noted at a BILTIR conference panel about cross-border reinsurance that every NAIC president chooses a theme.

"My theme is 'mind the gap,'" Mais said.

In many areas, "there is an increasing coverage gap," Mais said. "Probably, the biggest single gap is in retirement products. People need more life products. People need more annuities."

But, over the period after the 2007-2009 financial crisis, when central bankers kept interest rates especially low in an effort to nurse struggling borrowers back to health, "the capacity to support those products was nil," Mais said.

Regulators' job has been to understand and monitor the new reinsurance, investment and capital-raising strategies used to address the product supply gap, Mais said.

What it means: U.S. life and annuity issuers need Bermuda to help revive their sputtering supply of capital.

The backdrop: U.S. life and annuity issuers depend on investment earnings on stored-up premiums as well as the premium revenue to fund their product obligations.

Bermuda tends to make it easier for reinsurers based there to invest in instruments that come with more market risk or duration risk but pay higher returns.

U.S. life insurers have reinsured more than $600 billion in life and annuity business through Bermuda reinsurers since 2017, according to Moody's.

Some observers, including Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., have asked whether private equity-backed owners and increasing use of offshore reinsurance are weakening consumer protections.

Bermuda is developing new capital counting regulations meant to address observers' concerns, but officials there note that the European Union already classifies Bermuda as a jurisdiction with standards equivalent to the EU's own Solvency II standards and that the NAIC already classifies it as a reciprocal jurisdiction.

Astrid Jaekel, the chief risk officer at Aegon, said at the BILTIR conference that Aegon likes operating in Bermuda because it understands that life insurers can use illiquid assets and careful asset-liability matching strategies to support long-term life and annuity products.

Regulators' views: Mais, the NAIC president, acknowledged the need for careful regulatory monitoring, or "guardrails."

"The number one goal is consumer protection," Mais said. "You have to ensure solvency. Is a company able to pay? And market conduct: Is the company willing to pay? But it goes beyond that."

In addition to making sure that the products that exist are safe, regulators have to make sure that consumers benefit from having access to a vibrant, competitive insurance marketplace, Mais said.

"We don't want to stifle the market," he said. "We're a market that supports innovation."

Craig Swann, the chief executive officer of the Bermuda Monetary Authority, the agency that oversees Bermuda insurers and reinsurers, said private equity firms and the Bermuda reinsurance market are critical to overcoming the damage that low interest rates did to life and annuity issuers after the financial crisis.

Swann cited Swiss Re estimates that, as of 2022, the world faced a $106 trillion retirement assets gap.

One reason for the gap is that, from 2012 through 2022, the returns life and annuity issuers were earning on their invested assets were so poor that, instead of writing new annuities and pension plans, they ended up returning $275 billion in capital to shareholders in the form of dividends and share buybacks.

The alternative insurer view: Darryl Herrick, co-head of reinsurance at Global Atlantic, and Michael Pagano, head of insurance coverage in the financial institutions group at Apollo, defended the approach that the new private equity owners are taking to managing life and annuity reinsurance companies and those companies' investment portfolios.

Assets that are relatively illiquid, or difficult to convert quickly into cash, can be just as safe as the high-grade corporate bonds that life and annuity issuers have traditionally put in their portfolios, and there is no reason for long-term institutional investors, or long-term retail retirement investors, to accept low returns in exchange for a high level of liquidity, Herrick and Pagano said.

"Why do we have daily liquid index funds in our 401(k)s?" Pagano asked. "That's the longest liability that you've got on your balance sheet. That's the retirement income the individual is meant to be saving for. They can turn that into cash tomorrow. Why? What is the reason for that?"

Grotto Bay Beach Resort & Spa in Hamilton Parish, Bermuda. Credit: Nicola Muirhead/Bloomberg

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center