How to Talk to Clients Who Fear the End of the Bull Market

Commentary September 12, 2024 at 03:39 PM
Share & Print

What You Need To Know

  • Volatility is back (and it's normal), but that doesn't mean a bear market is around the corner.
  • By historical averages, the current bull market has not been running for very long.
  • The coming rate-cutting cycle could buoy the stock market for months.
Bull and bear on a 2024 calendar

Since the bull market began its run after the pandemic, its resistance to contrary forces has been astonishing.

This congenitally strong bull, the first since World War II to develop amid a Federal Reserve rate-hiking cycle, has galloped unhindered by the influence of doubting Thomases fearing an economic crash landing. 

Long overdue for a correction, this robust bovine seemed to defy its beastly mortality — until early August. Then, led by declines in tech stocks, the S&P 500 took its deepest dip since the fall of 2022. For clients unfamiliar with market history, this bull suddenly proved mortal. 

Mortal but, as things have turned out, resilient. From its July peak to its trough the following month (after precipitous sessions Aug. 2 and Aug. 5), the S&P 500 fell nearly 10%. But by late August, the index had rebounded to within one percentage point of an all-time high. Though volatility has continued into September, the index remains less than 2% below that high-water mark.

Some clients, having mistaken this bull's resilience for some kind of immortality, may be feeling a bit rattled. The herky-jerky line of indexes lately has caused some to see risk they didn't before. 

Here are some talking points to ease clients' fears:

Pullbacks and corrections are a normal part of the market. The market pullback was long overdue, and if anything, the recent dips were good buying opportunities. Expecting market growth without pullbacks and corrections is like expecting your investments to grow in a diagonal line, as they fictitiously did for Bernie Madoff's damaged investors.

In the real world, uninterrupted gains just don't happen. The market is about average gains from moving three steps forward and one step back.

Volatility is a natural part of the market and shouldn't be confused with risk because the two are very different. That's the view of Warren Buffett, who regrets the way the two are conflated at business schools. The actual problem with volatility, he says, is that it can prompt investors to do "stupid things," such as selling without a good reason.

Volatility is only an issue for short-term investors. Over the long haul, for disciplined long-term investors, it doesn't matter much because they benefit from long-term averages that make short-term volatility moot.

By historical averages, in terms of duration alone, this bull is by no means long in the tooth. It may be closer to its beginning than its end, based on the market's modern history of short bears and long bulls. 

According to data from First Trust, the average bull market since 1942 has lasted 4.3 years, with an average cumulative total return of 149%, as measured by the S&P 500. The average bear market in this modern period has lasted 11.1 months, with an average cumulative loss of -31.7%. If the current bull is only half done at its current age of 19 months, an implied total lifespan of 38 months would still make it 14 months short of the modern average of 52 months.

Widely respected economists, including Jeremy Siegel and Ed Yardeni, cite various factors likely to drive this bull much longer, beyond 2025. Yardeni sees the rest of this decade as the Roaring 2020s, with strong industrial growth. The digital industrial revolution, which started in the 1990s, continues to be strong today from the AI trade — a juggernaut that's transforming global business, industrial and consumer trends.

Technological advances of course benefit non-tech companies from the efficiencies and enhanced products they enable. And technology has become critical to the functionality of products of many non-tech industrial companies.

Technological advances enable increased economic productivity. That's the secret sauce of the economy that enables strong growth without accompanying increases in inflation. And this in turn will probably enable the Fed to keep interest rates lower for longer, enabling stock market growth, after a cutting cycle expected to start in September. The coming cutting cycle could buoy the stock market for months.

These and other long-term structural factors point to the likelihood of a bull market that may be with us well into 2025 or even longer.

Sure, this bull is mortal. But, as pullbacks and corrections are inevitable, the rebound only underscores a key virtue of this mortality: true resilience. 

Credit: Chris Nicholls/ALM; Adobe Stock


Dave Sheaff Gilreath, CFP, is a founder and chief investment officer of Sheaff Brock Investment Advisors, an investment firm for individual investors, and Innovative Portfolios, an institutional money management firm, both based in Indianapolis. As of June 30, the firms managed assets totaling about $1.4 billion.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center