Close Close
Popular Financial Topics Discover relevant content from across the suite of ALM legal publications From the Industry More content from ThinkAdvisor and select sponsors Investment Advisor Issue Gallery Read digital editions of Investment Advisor Magazine Tax Facts Get clear, current, and reliable answers to pressing tax questions
Luminaries Awards
ThinkAdvisor

Portfolio > ETFs

New Ways to Help Clients Move Beyond the 60/40 Portfolio

X
Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

What You Need to Know

  • The transparent ETF wrapper is increasingly an investment vehicle of choice, especially for taxable accounts.
  • Advisors have been sidestepping interest rate risk of fixed income and increased correlations between stocks and bonds.
  • Derivatives became a dirty word during the global financial crisis, but new tax-efficient, transparent, options-based strategies can help clients meet their goals.

The evolution of investment technology, options markets and regulations around derivatives has expanded the solution set that advisors can choose from to design portfolios for retirees and pre-retirees. There are now tax-efficient, transparent, options-based exchange-traded funds that can help advisors better match risk tolerance with desired outcomes for clients who are battling inflation, longevity and volatility.

For those wary of traditional balanced portfolios, like the 60/40 stock and bond mix, options-based, structured outcome strategies that precisely manage risk are stirring advisors’ attention.

In the wake of the global financial crisis, derivatives — securities that extend beyond options into credit default swaps — became a dirty word. Their proliferation, opacity of ownership and mismanagement in risk models became key issues. Over the past decade and a half, however, much has changed to erase that stain, including the maturation of the exchange-listed options markets, centralized clearing, better risk management procedures industrywide and improved plumbing that underpins markets.

Today, innovative exchange-listed options investment strategies built on improved market structure and embedded into the transparent ETF wrapper — increasingly an investment vehicle of choice, especially for taxable accounts — are revolutionizing traditional retiree portfolios beyond classic stock-bond strategies.

Over recent decades, bond funds have typically provided the risk management function in balanced portfolios that most financial advisors suggest to clients nearing or in retirement. Until recently, bonds remained mostly inversely correlated since the late 1990s. Bond prices would rise when stocks — which helped clients grow their savings and outpace inflation — would fall. Baby boomers did very well in a 60/40 portfolio during this period.

Advisors and their clients got a rude awakening, however, in the relationship between yields and bond prices during the recent rate rise cycle. While retirees may welcome higher yields, the value of their bond portfolios took a beating as the Federal Reserve hiked rates at a record clip from March 2022 to July 2023. The bond market remains in its longest drawdown, and the average intermediate-term bond fund is still deep in the red from a peak in summer 2020.

Options, however, allow for systematic risk management strategies that protect a portion, or all, of the downside over an outcome period while allowing an investor to participate in the stock market’s upside to a cap. This measure of equity market-linked capital appreciation potential is typically well more than what can be earned from holding bonds, especially in an environment whereby investors cannot expect significant price appreciation in fixed income funds. 

Today, with the federal funds rate more normalized, higher rates allow ETF sponsors to move beyond partial capital protection, or a buffer, to provide full capital protection, or 100% downside protection strategies, with meaningful upside caps. With capital-protected strategies, advisors can trade the certainty of the risk-free rate for the opportunity to gain about double the risk-free rate from linking their capital to the upside of the equity market. 

Yet, funds with options-based equity exposure can carry bond-like risk, with standard deviation lower than intermediate core bond funds and similar to short-term bonds. 

Such strategies, typically called fixed indexed annuities in the retirement income industry, are proving more popular than ever. These annuities recorded record sales in 2023 and across the first half of 2024, according to LIMRA. 

But 100% downside protection is now available in the ETF vehicle for a fraction of the average annuity’s price. The ETF carries the added advantages of not having surrender charges, illiquidity nor tax inefficiency. Capital-protected ETFs provide potential for growth that is tax-deferred and paid at capital gains rates instead of normal income tax rates that fixed indexed annuities and other conservative allocations, like money market funds and short-term bond funds, are subject to. 

The liquid exchange-listed FLEX Options used in the ETFs have the added benefit of being centrally cleared on the Options Clearing Corp., a transparent, solvent and systemically significant financial institution that all options exchanges are built on. As such, they do not carry counterparty credit risk — which isn’t an issue until it is, as investors learned during the global financial crisis. 

Advisors are increasingly seeking solutions for aging clients. In coming years, the number of Americans hitting retirement age will peak, about 11,000 per day through 2027. These clients face inflation that can eat away at their purchasing power, volatility that can devastate retirement savings and longer lives that their savings need to stretch over. Independent advisors have seen the merits in taking some equity market risk off the table, sidestepping interest rate risk of fixed income and increased correlations between stocks and bonds. 

While RIAs have been early adopters of these options-based ETFs, driving the structured outcome ETF universe to about $52 billion in assets under management, according to Bloomberg Intelligence, the groundswell of interest is growing to other wealth management organizations.

Large national wealth firms are beginning to grasp the merit of options-based ETFs for risk management — and how they can benefit the bulk of their client base. 

It is an exciting time for advisors seeking to provide innovative solutions to manage client capital through retirement — a period likely to be longer and with challenges that are harder to foresee, both in markets and in life. New tools in the ETF wrapper using options are helping advisors show their value to this clientele, and advisors looking to future-proof their businesses and their clients’ retirements are leaning in. 


Matt Kaufman is a senior vice president and head of exchange-traded funds at Calamos Investments.


NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.