Close Close
Popular Financial Topics Discover relevant content from across the suite of ALM legal publications From the Industry More content from ThinkAdvisor and select sponsors Investment Advisor Issue Gallery Read digital editions of Investment Advisor Magazine Tax Facts Get clear, current, and reliable answers to pressing tax questions
Luminaries Awards
ThinkAdvisor
Retirement savings coins in a jar

Retirement Planning > Saving for Retirement

Retirement Looks Precarious for Most in Middle Class: Study

X
Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

What You Need to Know

  • Survey participants came from households with annual income between $50,000 and $199,000.
  • A quarter envision doing some form of paid work in retirement.
  • Only 15% of middle-class savers have annuities, and 34% have life insurance.

Only a fifth of middle-class Americans say they are very confident in their ability to fully retire or maintain a comfortable lifestyle throughout their retirement, according to a new study from the nonprofit Transamerica Center for Retirement Studies in collaboration with Transamerica Institute.

The study broadly defines the middle class as people with an annual household income between $50,000 and $199,000.

“The middle class symbolizes the American dream,” Catherine Collinson, chief executive and president of Transamerica Institute and TCRS, said in a statement. “In today’s chaotic environment, what are the middle class’s hopes, dreams and retirement prospects? What support is needed from policymakers to help ensure they can retire with dignity? Our new report seeks to answer these pressing questions.”

The Harris Poll conducted an online survey on behalf of Transamerica Institute and TCRS between Sept. 14 and Oct. 23 among a nationally representative sample of 10,002 adults, including 5,726 with a household income between $50,000 and $199,999. 

Middle-Class Finances

Middle-class survey participants reported that they are juggling financial priorities that include paying off debt, saving for retirement, building emergency savings, saving for a major purchase or life event and just getting by to cover basic living expenses.

Among middle-class respondents who are yet to retire, 49% said they expect to work beyond the traditional retirement age, and 52% plan to continue working after they retire. The report noted, however, that retirees’ actual experiences raise doubts about whether these expectations are realistic. 

The median age that middle-class retirees left the workforce is 62. Half retired sooner than planned, often because of employment or health-related issues.

The survey found that the middle class has yet to fully engage in retirement planning. Only 21% of respondents said they have a lot of working knowledge about personal finance, 24% have a financial strategy for retirement in the form of a written plan and 17% frequently discuss saving, investing and retirement planning with family and close friends. Just 34% of respondents said they use a professional financial advisor.

Perhaps as a result, only a quarter of middle-class respondents strongly agreed that they were building a large enough retirement nest egg, or had done so. As of late 2023, middle-class respondents who are not yet retired reported that they had saved an estimated median $66,000 in total household retirement accounts. Middle-class retirees reported an estimated median $186,000 in total household savings excluding home equity.

The middle class is counting on diverse sources of retirement income, according to the survey. Forty-five percent of respondents expect their primary source of retirement income to come from self-funded savings, including 401(k)s, 403(b)s, IRAs and/or other savings and investments. 

Twenty-seven percent said their primary source of retirement income would be Social Security, 11% said it would come from a company-funded pension plan and 9% expect income to come from continued work. Only 2% cited home equity or from an inheritance as a primary source of retirement income.

“By gaining knowledge and engaging in financial planning, the middle class can make better-informed decisions in their daily lives which could, in turn, improve their long-term retirement prospects,” Collinson said. “However, they also need better, stronger societal support.”

How the Middle Class Invests

People in the middle class who are saving for retirement outside the workplace or who are already retired are investing in many ways, according to the survey: 

  • Bank account: 71%
  • 401(k), 403(b), 457(b) or similar plan: 43%
  • IRA: 38%
  • Brokerage account: 37%
  • Primary residence: 35%
  • Life insurance policy: 34%

The survey found that those with household incomes of $100,000 to $199,000 are generally likelier as well to invest in these ways than those with lower incomes: 

  • Annuity: 15%
  • Cryptocurrency: 14%
  • Health savings account: 12%
  • Real estate other than primary residence: 11%
  • Business ownership: 8% 
  • Non-fungible tokens: 5%

Meaningful Lives and Dreams

The survey showed that most middle-class people have positive feelings about life, including having close relationships with family and friends, being generally happy, having a strong sense of purpose, having a positive view of aging and engaging in an active social life. 

However, some also often feel unmotivated and overwhelmed, frequently feel anxious and depressed, have trouble making ends meet and experience isolation and loneliness.

People in the middle class plan to live to a median age of 90, according to the survey. Fourteen percent think they will make it to 100 or older. Thirty-six percent said they are uncertain how long they will live — a reasonable answer given the nature of the survey question, Transamerica Institute and TCRS noted.

Middle-class respondents’ greatest retirement fears are outliving their savings and investments; declining health that requires long-term care; Social Security being reduced or ceasing to exist; cognitive decline, dementia and Alzheimer’s disease; and possible long-term care costs.

These are their top five retirement dreams:

  • Traveling: 67%
  • Spending more time with family and friends: 58%
  • Pursuing hobbies: 51%
  • Doing volunteer work: 23%
  • Taking care of their grandchildren: 20%

In addition, a quarter envision doing some form of paid work in retirement such as starting a business, pursuing an encore career and/or continuing to work in the same field.

Priorities to Bolster Retirement Security

The survey findings indicate that 65% of respondents want the president and Congress to help people have a financially secure retirement by addressing Social Security’s funding shortfalls. 

Other priorities include making out-of-pocket health care expenses and prescription drugs more affordable, ensuring that all workers can save for retirement in the workplace, increasing access to affordable housing and supporting family caregivers.

“Solving Social Security’s funding shortfalls does not have a clear-cut solution in the eyes of the middle class,” Collinson said. 

When asked how Congress should address Social Security’s funding shortfall, 41% of middle-class respondents suggested increasing the maximum earnings subject to payroll taxes, 37% said increasing the Social Security payroll tax rate, 31% said preserving retirement benefit payments for retirees in greatest need and 24% said raising the retirement age. 

Twenty-two percent did not know what actions Congress should take, and just 4% said that Congress should do nothing.

“Our nation faces a tremendous opportunity to future-proof our retirement system to help middle-class Americans protect their health, build wealth, and retire with dignity,” Collinson said. “A collective effort is needed among policymakers, industry, academics, and individuals and families to implement lasting solutions.” 


NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.