5 Reasons Annuity Surrenders Can Be a Good Thing

Analysis August 07, 2024 at 11:36 AM
Share & Print

What You Need To Know

  • Surrender charges make annuity business sticky.
  • Fees from surrenders can help issuer earnings.
  • Surrenders resulting from allocation decisions may fuel new annuity sales.
Chris Blunt. (Photo: F&G)

F&G Annuities & Life works hard to bring in new life and annuity business — and it's fine with some of the policies and contracts going away.

Chris Blunt, the company's chief executive officer, and Wendy Young, the chief financial officer, gave securities analysts a tutorial on annuity surrenders Tuesday during a conference call.

In theory, ideal annuity owners might be wedded to their contracts for life.

In reality, when conditions change, "it's actually smart for the customer to move into a new policy, to get better terms," Blunt said. "Agents are obviously incented to do that as well. So, they're doing well. And, actually, for us, it's not a bad thing at all. We're capturing surrender charge income."

What it means: Life and annuity insurers can do well both when business is coming in and, at least in some circumstances, when business is going out.

For clients, one moral might be to look hard at any life insurance policies or annuity contracts they're thinking of surrendering. If surrenders would be good for the issuers, maybe clients and professionals should look hard to see whether, after netting out all costs, surrenders are the best option for the clients.

The numbers: F&G held the analyst call to go over second-quarter results.

The Des Moines, Iowa-based life and annuity issuer did well during the quarter: It reported $198 million in net income on $1.2 billion in revenue and $52 billion in assets under management, up from $130 million in net income on $1.2 billion in gross sales in the year-earlier quarter.

Total gross sales increased to $4.4 billion, from $3 billion.

Annuity surrenders increased to $1.5 billion on $33 billion in balances, from $880 million on $31 billion in balances.

Here are five things Blunt and Young said about annuity surrenders, during the call.

1. A company like F&G offers a mix of products that can and can't be surrendered.

Surrendering the ordinary nonvariable indexed annuities and registered index-linked annuities is easy once surrender charge periods are up, but the company's immediate income annuities and the big group annuities the company sells to pension plan sponsors can't be surrendered.

2. Product terminations are a logical response to interest rate volatility.

Blunt compared the idea of replacing life and annuity products when interest rates change to refinancing a home mortgage when interest rates change.

Right now, he said, "it's actually smart for the customer to move into a new policy and get better terms."

3. Terminations let F&G steer through changing economic winds.

When clients surrender annuities, they typically pay surrender charge fees. The fees increase F&G's income.

The terminations also free up the capital supporting the annuities surrendered.

F&G can use the freed capital to write new annuities with higher surrender charges and longer surrender periods, Young said.

4. The cash value inside newer annuities sold and purchased could be locked up more tightly.

Many customers are moving cash from older, unwanted annuities into newer annuities.

"The stuff we're writing right now might prove to be some of the stickiest assets we've ever written," Young said. "Because if rates do, in fact, move down from here, it's going to be very hard to move those contracts prematurely."

5. F&G Annuities may benefit when interest rate changes push clients to overhaul their portfolios.

When clients change gears, "it benefits our own distribution, because some of the investments we've made have been in annuity-oriented [independent marketing organizations], and they're just crushing it in this environment," Blunt said. "Not only in terms of new sales, but obviously in terms of smart replacement sales."

Chris Blunt. Credit: F&G

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center