Dropbox Co-Founder Claims JPMorgan Advisor Cost Him Over $225M

News August 01, 2024 at 02:47 PM
Share & Print

What You Need To Know

  • The client relationship started before finance giant acquired First Republic Bank.
  • After confronting the advisor, the client was told to close his accounts, the suit says.
  • The plaintiff wants the court to allow his FINRA arbitration to proceed.
JPMorgan's New York Headquarters

Dropbox co-founder Arash Ferdowsi filed a lawsuit Wednesday alleging that an advisor at J.P. Morgan Private Wealth Advisors steered him into "highly improper" investments that caused him over $225 million in damages.

Ferdowsi asks the court to allow him to pursue a Financial Industry Regulatory Authority arbitration against J.P. Morgan Private Wealth Advisors, J.P. Morgan Securities and advisor Arif Ahmed without interference from the lawsuit's two defendants — JPMorgan Chase Bank and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. as receiver for the failed First Republic Bank.

"These investments were selected for no legitimate investment purpose, but rather because they allowed JPM Wealth to extract over $40 million in hidden fees that it then shared with Ahmed," Ferdowsi and his revocable trust allege in the complaint filed in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.

"Ahmed steered Ferdowsi into complex, low-performing investment vehicles with exorbitant embedded fees that were fifteen times higher than the advisory fees that Ferdowsi and Ahmed had agreed upon," the billionaire entrepreneur alleges in the lawsuit.

"To make matters worse, Ahmed compounded his rent-seeking strategy by churning Ferdowsi's account, recommending unnecessarily early and frequent trades. Each of these trades lined Ahmed's and JPM Wealth's pockets with further fees while causing ever-increasing harm to Ferdowsi's portfolio," the complaint says.

More Details

When Ferdowsi first discovered the improper fees in December and confronted Ahmed about them, "Ahmed evaded and lied. Soon after, JPM Wealth informed Ferdowsi — without any explanation — that he had a matter of weeks to close all of his investment accounts before they would be liquidated," the complaint alleges.

"Ahmed and JPM Wealth's fraudulent mismanagement of Ferdowsi's investments, compounded by their retaliatory closing of his accounts, violated their fiduciary and other common-law duties, a host of applicable FINRA rules, and federal securities laws," it contends.

Ferdowsi seeks to recoup the alleged damages through a FINRA arbitration case, filed Tuesday, which names the three parties he considers responsible: Ahmed, J.P. Morgan Private Wealth Advisors and J.P. Morgan Securities.

His FINRA case claims that these parties violated Securities and Exchange Commission regulations and notes that the SEC requires brokers to place investors' interests before their own under Regulation Best Interest.

The lawsuit alleges that from April 2020 to October 2023, "prominent" advisor Ahmed advised Ferdowsi to invest in dozens of complex structured notes, called Market-Linked Investments, to gain market exposure to the technology sector.

The relationship started before and continued after JPMorgan Chase acquired First Republic Bank and its investment subsidiaries after the California-based bank's failure last year.

Ahmed and JPM Wealth, however, "failed to inform Ferdowsi that the MLIs were specifically designed to include large, embedded fees paid to JPM Wealth. Those fees were many multiples greater than the fees on similar investments that Ferdowsi could have invested in.

"Moreover, Ahmed had agreed with Ferdowsi that JPM Wealth would be compensated through a flat 0.25% financial-advisory fee that would not be affected by the selection of any particular investments," the suit contends.

The fees, disguised as "underwriting discounts," typically amounted to 3.75% of the MLI purchase price, or 15 times the agreed-upon advisory fee, the suit alleges.

Alleged: Over $40M in Fees

Ahmed and JPM Wealth collected over $40 million in fees from Ferdowsi's investments by churning his account through repeated MLI purchases, "which totaled a staggering $1 billion across 35 investments," the complaint alleges

JPM Wealth paid a substantial portion of those fees to Ahmed, who became one of First Republic Investment Management's highest-paid financial advisors as a result, it contends.

Ahmed and JPM Wealth's misconduct occurred both before and after the May 1, 2023, closure of First Republic Bank, and they sold Ferdowsi over $100 million of MLIs after that date, causing "significant harm to his portfolio," the complaint alleges.

"By steering Ferdowsi into MLIs rather than suitable investments such as index funds or large-cap technology stocks, Ahmed and JPM Wealth caused Ferdowsi to sustain total damages of over $225 million," it states. 

Ahmed, registered as a J.P. Morgan Securities broker and J.P. Morgan Private Wealth Advisors investment advisor, faces two customer disputes filed Feb. 6, according to FINRA's BrokerCheck. One alleges over $35 million in losses and the other nearly $205 million.

He recruited Ferdowsi in 2020 to join other wealthy San Francisco-area tech entrepreneurs in entrusting his wealth to First Republic Investment Management, the lawsuit says. Ferdowsi contends that his First Republic brokerage agreement allows him to pursue dispute arbitration with FINRA.

Though they are not parties to his FINRA dispute, JPMorgan Chase Bank and the FDIC argue that Ferdowsi's claims should be brought through the administrative claims process in the FDIC's First Republic Bank receivership rather than FINRA, the lawsuit states.

First Republic Issues

J.P. Morgan Private Wealth Advisors and J.P. Morgan Securities previously operated as First Republic Investment Management and First Republic Securities Company — wholly owned subsidiaries of First Republic Bank, which the FDIC sold to JPMorgan Chase on May 1, 2023, after First Republic's failure.

The FDIC and JPMorgan Chase contend that while JPMorgan acquired these two First Republic Bank subsidiaries in their entirety, the FDIC retains liability for the matter.

This position is baseless, Ferdowsi argues, as FRIM and FRSC "were never placed in receivership, are not FDIC depository institutions, and have been not only solvent but hugely profitable both before and after First Republic Bank's failure."

Even after JPMorgan's acquisition of the two First Republic subsidiaries last year, "they continued to operate independently for several months, continued to collect significant fees from Ferdowsi and mismanage his accounts, and were not rebranded to be part of the JPMorgan franchise until almost six months later. 

"They are merely two assets — wholly distinct corporations — among many others that JPM Bank acquired as a result of First Republic Bank's failure," the complaint says.

JPMorgan and FDIC's "implied threats" to interfere with the FINRA arbitration are credible, as they've done so recently in other cases, according to the lawsuit.

JPMorgan declined to comment on the case, a spokesperson told ThinkAdvisor by email Thursday. The FDIC won't comment on ongoing litigation, a spokesman told ThinkAdvisor by email.

Credit: Bloomberg

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center