Close Close
Popular Financial Topics Discover relevant content from across the suite of ALM legal publications From the Industry More content from ThinkAdvisor and select sponsors Investment Advisor Issue Gallery Read digital editions of Investment Advisor Magazine Tax Facts Get clear, current, and reliable answers to pressing tax questions
Luminaries Awards
ThinkAdvisor
A home care aide with a woman who needs care. Via DAMS.

Life Health > Long-Term Care Planning

Stop Talking About Nursing Homes

X
Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

What You Need to Know

  • No one wants to think about spending a year in a nursing home.
  • Some will think about spending a year getting home care.
  • Few clients will understand how much home care costs.

When planning for extended care, many consumers and their advisors make the mistake of starting from the end, by assuming and projecting the highest possible cost of care in a private-pay, private skilled nursing home room.

According to the most recent data from the Genworth Cost of Care survey report, which was published in December, the national average for a year in a private nursing home room is $116,800. Multiply that by several years of care, and those are scary numbers indeed.

But no one wants to plan to go to a nursing home. It’s the last place anyone wants to receive care.

Proactive, advanced planning for extended care is preparation for staying out of a nursing home, by making enough private-pay dollars available — through insurance or insurance combined with a client’s own income and assets — to pay for home care, or for assisted living or residential memory care, when home care is not possible or no longer practical.

Advisors shouldn’t focus the extended care planning conversation on a recitation of scary statistics and the highest possible cost of care in a nursing home. Instead, they should begin with a question: “If possible, for as long as possible, would you want to receive care in your own home?”

Most clients will answer, “Yes!” Those who don’t want home care may not have a spouse or children close by to be informal care managers and will recognize that residential care should be a planning priority, but this doesn’t necessarily mean care in a nursing home.

Focus on what clients want to plan for and what will impact their family and finances first: home care.

Even without a purposeful extended care plan, couples and other family members will default to doing everything possible to keep a loved one at home, often to the detriment of the informal caregiver. Therefore, a proactive plan for care must address this desire and the many costs — both financial and personal — that must be covered.

According to the Genworth Cost of Care survey, the national average for a professional home care aide is $33 per hour. Forty hours a week of home care therefore may cost just over $5,700 a month. Consider asking your clients this first: “If you need care, where will you get an extra $5,700 a month to pay for part-time home care?” This question is profoundly important for couples where the greatest financial pressure is when one spouse needs care while they are both still alive. Home care costs will be extra over and above ongoing lifestyle expenses for both and the need to preserve the future financial security of a surviving spouse.

Of course, 24/7 home care is the most expensive care, exceeding $250,000, even more than a private room in a nursing home; a few very wealthy clients may want to plan for this level of care, but that’s an exception.

Even clients with several million dollars under management would struggle to afford an extra $5,000 to $6,000 a month of long-term care expenses without seriously compromising the lifestyle and financial security of a spouse or partner. Extra hours or days of home care quickly increase the cost. Twelve hours a day, seven days a week would cost $12,000 a month in 2024.

Practically, very few people have both the financial means and the capacity to manage round-the-clock professional care at home. Once care needs require more than eight to 10 hours of professional care per day, that’s often when the decision will be made to transition to residential care, such as assisted living. According to Genworth, assisted living costs are similar to home care, $5,350 monthly on average. It’s important to recognize that these survey costs are average, baseline room-and-board costs, with minimal personal care services, and the cost of assisted living increases quickly with higher levels of care.

Again, how will this monthly expense of $5,000 a month or more be covered above all other ongoing financial priorities?

Single clients who are more likely to move to residential care sooner may not need to purchase as high a monthly benefit, as a couple as they can shift their income from paying for independent lifestyle to help pay for care without worry about compromising a spouse’s ongoing lifestyle. But can a single person adequately cover the full potential monthly cost from income? What other financial priorities may also need to continue?

Long-term care insurance becomes a co-insurance tool, to pay for the type of private-pay care desired: the services that allow a person to stay out of a nursing home.

Advisors must help clients plan for the kind of care they actually want. For most people this means home care first as an extra expense for which they must plan, and they must be insured at a meaningful level to preserve both ongoing lifestyle and future financial security. This “home care first” focus also allows clients to see the value in a more affordable, lower-benefit-amount policy design.


Fountain pen (Image: iStock)Bill Comfort, CLTC, is director of training at the Corporation for Long Term Care Certification and the owner of Comfort Long Term Care.

 ..

..

..

..

Credit: Kasco/iStock


NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.