Is a Market Melt-Up Coming? Here Are the Risks to Watch: Ed Yardeni

Q&A May 21, 2024 at 01:39 PM
Share & Print

Ed Yardeni, founder of Yardeni Research Inc.

Stock market indexes are at record highs, inflation is gradually abating and interest rates are expected to stay at their current level or perhaps decrease.

Significant risks remain, however, and to protect clients' assets, financial advisors should take note of them.

"The Fed is no longer the biggest risk to the economy, earnings and valuations because it has stopped raising interest rates. … Current rates are normal … zero rates was the abnormality," Edward Yardeni, president of Yardeni Research, argues in a recent interview with ThinkAdvisor.

In the interview, Yardeni discusses the risks that financial advisors should be watching, such as a potential credit crunch and geopolitical threats, plus a wild card: the presidential election.

Yardeni, whose consultancy clients include institutional portfolio managers and government policymakers, lays out three scenarios for the economy and targets highs for the S&P 500 for 2024 and the next two years.

The bull market "can continue, unless it becomes too much of a good thing," says Yardeni, previously chief investment strategist at Deutsche Bank's U.S. equities division and an economist with the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

He is alluding to a stock melt-up (followed by a meltdown), which he discusses, as well as the sort of investor who would lead it.

Here are highlights of our conversation:

THINKADVISOR: The stock market is setting a record. So are we in a melt-up? If so, what are the implications?

EDWARD YARDENI: I don't know that we're in a melt-up just yet. That word immediately draws the conclusion that it will be followed by a meltdown. 

But I view a melt-up as a great opportunity to make a lot of money as long as we get out at the top, which is always tricky because everybody gets into the irrational exuberance of the experience and forgets to get out.

And then we give back a lot, or actually lose.

What would trigger a melt-up?

It would be led by a lot of FOMO buyers. They've already missed 50% of the increase in the market since Oct. 12, 2022, the bottom of the previous bear market. A lot of investors are just sitting there in money market funds.

If they all start jumping in during the last leg of the bull market, there could be a melt-up. That could get the multiple up to levels that make the market vulnerable to a meltdown — a very intense sell-off. 

But that doesn't last very long, and then the bull market resumes.

What do you make of Mr. Market's current behavior?

For now, the market buys the idea that we're going to continue to see the economy grow and inflation continue to moderate and that the Fed will either leave interest rates where they are or lower them.

Please elaborate.

I hope the Fed doesn't cut interest rates because they aren't too high for the economy to grow. 

These are normal rates, bringing us back to where they were before the great financial crisis through the great virus crisis, when we had zero interest rates. That was the abnormality.

How long do you think the bull market will go on?

It can continue to keep going unless it becomes too much of a good thing, which means that my targets are going to be achieved way ahead of schedule.

What are your targets?

For the S&P 500, 5,400 by the end of this year. If we get there by next week, I'm going to start wondering whether [the market is] showing increasing signs of a melt-up.

For next year, I'm looking for 6,000, and for the year after that, 6,500. 

What should financial advisors be most wary of right now to protect their clients' assets?

You're looking for risk factors that can hurt revenues, profit margins and therefore earnings. You're always looking for variables that might depress the valuation multiple.

I think the Fed is no longer the biggest risk to the economy, earnings and valuations because it has stopped raising interest rates. And I don't expect that we'll get [signs] that inflation will be higher than expected, which would force the Fed to raise rates.

The main risk would be that rates are too high and the Fed doesn't lower them fast enough. But that's not my view. [As I said], the economy can handle these rates. They're normal rather than highly restrictive.

What else should advisors be watching?

A credit crunch would be a concern because in the past, that's a process that typically has led to a recession: Something breaks in the financial system, and in turn that leads to a credit crunch and then to a recession. 

So it's important to keep an eye out for any stresses in the credit markets.

What about geopolitical worries?

The geopolitical risk is still there: Another thing that's been associated with recession — but that I'm not particularly concerned about is a sharp, significant increase in the price of oil and therefore gasoline. 

If oil prices spike, that could ignite inflation. This would be a replay of the 1970s.

In the past three years, we've had the most widely anticipated recession of all that's never happened. I took the contrarian position that we weren't going to have one.

What are the most likely scenarios that you see unfolding in the economy?

A 60% probability of a "Roaring 20s" scenario. And I'd say, so far so good.

There's a 20% probability of a replay of the 1990s, which would be a melt-up scenario.

The remaining 20% probability scenario is a replay of the 1970s.

The first two are totally bullish. The third would be the bearish one, when geopolitical factors lead to an energy crisis and rebounding inflation that would force the Fed to raise interest rates and cause a recession. 

What's the wild card?

[The presidential] election. We don't actually know the policies of these [two] politicians because they're so extreme. Trump and Biden clearly have extreme policy alternatives that could create problems.

They're both deficit doves. Both of them might very well continue to exacerbate the federal deficit problem. Trump could push for an extension of his tax cuts or even an expansion during his first term. 

Biden might very well push for even more spending and more debt forgiveness for student debt.

So if the deficit just keeps growing, what could happen?

There's the risk of a debt crisis. The Treasury would have to continue to raise more and more money in the government auctions.

At some point, the bond market may rebel and push yields up to levels that will cause a recession because it's so hard to find buyers. 

But the better-than-expected growth and lower-than-expected inflation — which might allow the Fed to lower interest rates somewhat — will push that day of reckoning down the road, as [has been the case] for years.

What's your thinking about the way the Federal Reserve has handled inflation and interest rates over the past few years?

I've been siding with the Fed and saying, "I think they might actually get it right."

I've been a contrarian taking the position that the Fed's scenario might be the correct one. Chair Jerome Powell has been saying that there was a narrow path they might be able to go down in which inflation would moderate without a recession.

He talked about a bump in the road along the way to bringing inflation down. 

What happened in the first three months of this year [high inflation] was that bump exactly.

Now we're back on the smoother path toward 2% inflation by the end of the year.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center