Ex-Morgan Stanley Advisor Says Co-Worker Proposed Honeypot Scheme

News February 29, 2024 at 02:25 PM
Share & Print

What You Need To Know

  • The male co-worker's suggestion, as the advisor understood, was to use her looks to attract clients.
  • She contends that a toxic work environment led her to resign in 2022.
  • The financial services company denies the allegations.
A statue showing the goddess of justice holding up scales. (Image: Adobe Stock)

A former Morgan Stanley financial advisor has filed a discrimination and harassment lawsuit against the firm, her male supervisor and a male colleague, alleging that the co-worker proposed running a honeypot operation to attract clients, among other toxic behavior.

Within the first three months that they worked together, the colleague proposed to plaintiff  "that they run 'operation honeypot,' where (she) and her other attractive female friends would go to events with (his) 'rich guy friends,'" the lawsuit filed last week in Superior Court of New Jersey alleges.

She understood this to be a suggestion "that she should use her sex and her looks to 'woo' clients and or engage in quid pro quo to secure new clients," the lawsuit contends.

Morgan Stanley hired Stewart as a financial advisor in January 2019 and in October that year promoted her to director of insurance and planning; she also continued her work as a financial advisor, according to the complaint.

Unable to tolerate the allegedly discriminatory, hostile and retaliatory environment, she resigned in May 2022, a move that Stewart describes as a constructive discharge.

When she was hired, Stewart reported directly to Richard Maratea and was partnered with Evan Silverman in her advising business, the lawsuit notes. Both men are defendants, along with Morgan Stanley Financial Advisors and others. Morgan Stanley's website currently lists Maratea as branch manager in the company's Mt. Laurel, New Jersey, office,

Maratea was responsible for enforcing anti-discrimination and anti-retaliation policies in connection with Stewart's employment but "deliberately violated those duties," she contends.

Soon after she started working for Morgan Stanley, Stewart alleges, she learned that the defendants had misrepresented Silverman's skills, credentials and experience, and he started to demonstrate a lack of professionalism toward and about her in the workplace.

As a result, Stewart struggled to perform her duties while also ensuring that Silverman's work was being done properly and in accordance with regulations, the lawsuit contends.

While she performed her duties in a commendable manner, Stewart "was subjected to demeaning comments and harassing behavior" by Maratea and Silverman based on her gender, she alleges.

When Stewart alerted Maratea to her issues with Silverman on various occasions in 2019 and 2020, Maratea was dismissive and made repeated references to his and Silverman's belief that she was distracted from her work, the suit contends.

Maratea also indicated that he didn't believe the firm had gotten its money's worth from her considering money expended defending Stewart in litigation with her prior employer, and that Silverman "was carrying the weight of their partnership," she alleges.

Silverman continued to engage in discriminatory or disparaging remarks about Stewart, including discussing her dating life and prior marriage with other men in the workplace and referring to her as "Female Financial Advisor" or "sexual harassment panda," a reference to a character on the TV show "South Park," she alleges.

In addition, Stewart contends that Silverman shared her personal information with her former boyfriend, leading her to become a victim of home invasion and several violent assaults by that ex-boyfriend and having to seek a restraining order, according to the lawsuit.

She also alleges that Silverman asked a lawyer if he thought she was sleeping with a client, and that when clients or prospects gave her a hard time, he would comment that "this is why Tara is single."

Among the allegations she made about Maratea's conduct, Stewart contends that he watched a video at work in which a comedian discussed the difference between men's and women's brains; implied that Stewart came to work drunk or hungover; failed to support her in pursuing new clients; and directed Silverman not to work on her accounts.

The supervisor also pushed Stewart "to get more money from a particular client, which (she) understood to be a directive to engage in quid pro quo," the lawsuit says.

In June 2021, Stewart scheduled a meeting with Maratea's supervisor to discuss her concerns about the work environment, and when Maratea learned she had scheduled the meeting, he insisted she should follow the "chain of command" and speak to him first, according to the suit.

In September that year, the defendants "ambushed" Stewart with a phone call with at least five people "launching unfounded internal investigation on several different fronts," the suit contends, adding that she considered the investigation retaliatory in nature.

Morgan Stanley repeatedly failed to respond to or address Stewart's complaints of discrimination, retaliation and a hostile work environment, she contends.

She alleges that the defendants violated New Jersey's anti-discrimination law, created a hostile work environment, subjected her to retaliation and caused her constructive discharge by allowing intolerable conditions that would lead a reasonable person to resign.

Stewart contends that she filed a formal complaint about the allegedly toxic work environment with Morgan Stanley's human resources department and contacted a company vice president about the matter.

A Morgan Stanley spokesperson provided the following comment to ThinkAdvisor on Wednesday:

"Morgan Stanley is committed to maintaining a professional work environment and denies the allegations in the complaint. These allegations were not asserted by Ms. Stewart prior to her voluntary resignation from the firm in May 2022, which triggered her obligation to repay substantial loans."

Silverman didn't immediately respond to a message sent through LinkedIn.

Stewart is currently a registered broker and investment advisor with Cetera Advisor Networks and Cetera Investment Advisers, respectively, according to the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority's BrokerCheck database. She's listed as a managing director on Allied Wealth Management's website.

BrokerCheck indicates that she filed for bankruptcy protection last year.

Image: Sergign/Adobe Stock

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center