Allianz Life Responds to Suit Involving Agent Oversight Questions

News January 31, 2024 at 10:48 AM
Share & Print

Allianz Life Insurance Co. of North America asserts that, under California law, it has no duty to act as a fiduciary for an insured and is not subject to a professional standard of care.

The company made those points in a demurrer filed recently in a California state court in Los Angeles County.

Allianz Life was responding to a suit filed by Layne Kramer and a Kramer family trust. Kramer says the insurer should have warned her after her former insurance agent, David Neuman, was convicted of embezzling benefit payments from another client and left the company.

"Allianz Life intends to vigorously defend itself from these allegations," a company representative said. "It should be noted the agent in question was not affiliated with Allianz Life at the time of his alleged wrongdoings."

Representatives for Kramer and Neuman did not respond to a request for comment.

The history: Kramer and a Kramer family trust say in their complaint that Neuman tied up assets Kramer needed to pay for her elderly mother's care by selling her non-variable indexed annuities in 2014.

In 2018, after Neuman was convicted of embezzlement and left Allianz Life, he continued to help Kramer with financial matters, and he had her make him the trustee of a trust.

Neuman took $330,000 of Kramer's annuity assets by changing the mailing address of the trust to his home address, according to Kramer's complaint.

Kramer said that, in addition to warning her about Neuman, Allianz Life should have looked into Neuman's move to have Kramer's assets go to his own home.

Demurrers: A demurrer is a document filed by a party to a lawsuit.

In a demurrer, the party assumes that most factual allegations made by the other side are correct and then tries to show that the other side' reasoning and interpretation of the law are wrong.

The Allianz Life demurrer: Allianz Life notes in the demurrer that Neuman persuaded Kramer to make him a trustee about 18 months after he stopped being an Allianz Life insurance agent.

In California, "courts routinely hold that because an insurer is not a fiduciary for its insured, it cannot be held liable for breach of fiduciary duties," according to the demurrer. "The only thing that plaintiffs have pled is a contractual relationship. That is not enough to create a fiduciary relationship."

Similarly, Allianz Life says, Allianz Life is not a professional and cannot be sued for professional negligence.

Credit: Shutterstock

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center