Mariner Recruited 'Double Agent' to Poach Clients, Lawsuit Claims

News January 23, 2024 at 02:23 PM
Share & Print

Mariner Wealth Advisors is facing two more lawsuits over alleged client poaching and attempts to steal trade secrets.

A Jan. 12 lawsuit filed by RWA Wealth Partners accuses Mariner of conducting a "clandestine scheme" to obtain an "unfair advantage in the wealth management industry by destabilizing the contractual relationships of a competitor, stealing its proprietary information, and accessing its computer data and network without permission."

Mariner Wealth's "clandestine plot," according to the suit, centered on the recruitment of "an 'inside man' — finding the perfect double agent in Brandon Berman, a then wealth manager for competitor Polaris Wealth Advisory Group, LLC."

In early 2022, RWA purchased Polaris Wealth Advisory Group, based in San Rafael, California.

Mariner, according to the RWA suit, "knew their 'inside man' was well-positioned to execute their subterfuge because Berman managed (or assisted in managing) more than one hundred of Polaris' client relationships and had access to Polaris' proprietary systems and client data."

'Benedict Arnold'

The suit alleges that Berman served a "Benedict Arnold role," and that Mariner "coached and directed him to surreptitiously feed them confidential and proprietary client data and business information, and to steal clients."

The suit continues: "Worse still, it appears that Defendants [Mariner] encourage their 'inside men' to do all of this before those people provide their employer any hint that they intend to resign and jump to" Mariner.

In March 2022, Berman informed Mariner that he had used Polaris' systems to create a client list "chock-full of proprietary information without Polaris' or Polaris' clients' permission or knowledge — a document he had creatively named 'the List,'" the suit states.

Upon learning this, Mariner "did not tell him to stop or to delete the document. Instead, it appears they arranged to speak with (and/or get information from) Berman's lawyers to create a cover story and develop a game plan to cover their collusion including a memo that provided tips and tricks on how to avoid getting caught when stealing confidential information (and plaintiff believes that there will be additional evidentiary support for this connection after a reasonable opportunity for further investigation or discovery)," the suit states.

Mariner, the suit states, "brazenly accepted 'the List' from Berman, with knowledge of the improper circumstances under which it was created and fully aware that Berman had no right to possess it and no right to give it" to Mariner.

Avantax Suit

In a lawsuit filed on Jan. 18, tax-centered planning firm Avantax claims a former employee, Michael Carignan, jumped ship and joined Mariner and is now, with Mariner's knowledge and support, "soliciting and tortiously interfering with the relationships between Avantax" and its CPA clients.

Immediately upon resigning his employment with Avantax — now part of Cetera — Carignan started his employment with Mariner "and began doggedly pursuing Avantax's clients to leave Avantax and move their business to Mariner, including CPA firm clients Avantax gave Carignan to service, and through which he received significant primary and bonus compensation," the suit states.

Carignan, according to the suit, "has engaged in solicitation of CPA firm clients and end-user clients with which he worked at Avantax, with the intention of requesting that such clients cease doing business with Avantax and begin doing business with Mariner."

Within one week of moving to Mariner, "Carignan has already successfully solicited and converted at least 16 Avantax client accounts to Mariner," the suit states.

The suit goes on to contend that Mariner has asissted Carignan in misappropriating the trade secrets of Avantax, and that Mariner has "intentionally and improperly interfered" with enforceable non-solicitation contracts between Avantax and Carignan.

Mariner's "continuing improper and unjustified interference" with Avantax's agreements with Carignan "threatens Avantax with irreparable harm, including loss of business, injury to Avantax's customer goodwill, and disclosure of Avantax's trade secrets and confidential information," the suit contends.

Edelman Suit

In November, Edelman Financial Engines filed a lawsuit against Mariner Wealth Advisors for what it called an ongoing "unlawful scheme" to poach Edelman's clients and steal its business and trade secrets.

In that suit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas, Edelman contends that to date, Mariner has persuaded 10 Edelman planners to move their assets under management to the firm.

Mariner has not responded to requests for comment on the suits.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center