Groups Blast GOP Budget Over 'Death Panel' for Social Security

News September 19, 2023 at 05:04 PM
Share & Print

Social Security advocates are coming out against a House Budget Committee resolution released Tuesday that proposes a debt commission that could recommend cuts to Social Security and Medicare.

Nancy Altman, president of Social Security Works, said Tuesday in a statement that the White House "has accurately labeled a commission as a 'death panel' for Social Security. The only reason to make changes to Social Security via a closed-door, fast-track commission is to cut benefits."

The resolution was released by House Budget Committee Chairman Jodey Arrington, R-Texas.

House Speaker Kevin McCarthy said in June that he was working to assemble a commission to look at potential cuts in spending across the entire federal government, including on key social insurance programs such as Social Security and Medicare.

The commisison is discussed on pages 76-78 of the Republican budget.

It states that the "United States faces a significant debt crisis, with the national debt currently standing at nearly $33 trillion. This debt poses a significant risk to the country's long-term fiscal sustainability, with implications for future generations. The drivers of U.S. debt include entitlement spending such as Social Security and Medicare and discretionary government spending. To address these challenges, a comprehensive review of the United States' current debt situation is necessary to ensure that the country's financial future is secure."

Republicans, Altman said, "desperately want Democrats to provide cover for Social Security cuts, which are rightfully unpopular with voters of all parties. This is why their budget calls for a 'bipartisan' commission. Democrats should refuse to cooperate. Instead, they should continue to work to protect and expand Social Security through regular Congressional order."

New Commission 'Much Weaker'

Maria Freese, senior legislative representative for the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare, said in an email to ThinkAdvisor that the new version of a commission included in the draft House budget resolution "is actually much weaker than most as it has no enforcement mechanism. Most other commissions include fast-track procedures to force votes on the House and Senate Floor without giving time for the public to understand what they are doing."

While the language in the budget resolution doesn't allow for fast-tracking or bypassing the legislative process, NCPSM worries that if a commission is created through legislative action it could include those provisions.

McCarthy, Freese explained, "could create this kind of commission any time he wanted to — and in fact he suggested he would earlier this year — assuming he could get Democrats willing to serve on it."

Mary Johnson, Social Security and Medicare policy analyst for The Senior Citizens League, said in another email Tuesday that a Point of Order on page 44 of the draft proposal "restricts changes to mandatory programs to $15 billion" in fiscal year 2024. "That would rule out boosting benefits and potentially make it difficult to raise payroll taxes," Johnson said.

Payroll taxes are Social Security's primary funding mechanism.

Maya MacGuiness, president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, said in a statement that the GOP plan's suggestion of a bipartisan commission to address the long-term fiscal situation "is a great idea that policymakers should adopt immediately."

This commission, MacGuiness opined, "is needed sooner rather than later to address the looming insolvency of Social Security and Medicare and tame the growth of the national debt."

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center