The Secrets Behind Commonwealth's Award-Winning Advisor Satisfaction

Q&A July 14, 2023 at 03:42 PM
Share & Print

Fresh off his firm's 10th consecutive J.D. Power honor for being the top investment firm for independent advisor satisfaction, Commonwealth Financial Network CEO Wayne Bloom pointed to the high level of engagement between advisors and management as the main factor in the firm's ability to achieve that award yet again.

That's also what helped Commonwealth achieve a strong year in advisor recruitment in 2022.

In the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Financial Advisor Satisfaction Study, Commonwealth received an overall satisfaction score of 798 on a 1,000-point scale, outpacing the next-highest-ranked firm by 101 points. Commonwealth achieved the highest score in all reported key drivers of advisor satisfaction: compensation, leadership and culture, professional development, products and marketing, operational support and technology.

"Without the input and suggestions of our advisors, who are at the center of our collective success, a recognition like this would be impossible — we're incredibly grateful," Bloom said in a statement. "It's only through the constant collaboration and communication we enjoy with the advisors who choose to partner with us that we can hold Commonwealth up as the #1 firm for the most satisfied independent advisors."

Many of the firm's advisor solutions have been created as the result of feedback on how the firm can improve and add to its suite of services to best help its affiliates drive success, it said.

Notable from the past year were flexible financing options to aid advisor growth and succession planning, enhanced offerings to support advisors with high-net-worth clients, and expanded outsourced business solutions to give advisors access to tools and resources that drive efficiency, according to the company.

During a phone interview with Bloom on Wednesday, he touched on these and other topics, including what keeps him up at night these days.

Bloom concluded, "These collective efforts are rooted in partnership and centered around our ability to continuously evolve alongside our advisors and afford them more time spent with their clients."

Here is an edited version of our interview.

THINKADVISOR: How was Commonwealth able to achieve 10 consecutive years of J.D. Power recognition? What are your secrets? 

WAYNE BLOOM: I'm really proud of the team internally that worked so hard on the advisors' behalf.

The feedback mechanism and loops that we have with the advisors and how we engage them not only [help] us do what we do and prioritize things. The manner in which we engage with them and take their feedback and bring them into a lot of our decisions is really what I consider the special sauce.

When the compliance auditors are out in the field doing their annual audit, they're collecting feedback, qualitative and quantitative. So we understand how we're doing and what [advisors] like and what they don't like.

Our practice management team, when they're doing their annual check, it's the same thing. What's going well? They're educating them on the new things that have come out they may not be aware of. But the crown jewel … the one that's most mechanized is this online tool that we have and there's a little plus sign on every page of our website.

And if an advisor or one of their staff clicks it, a dialogue box pops up and there's all kinds of categorization and then some free-form text that they could write in and they make comments, suggestions, complaints, kudos.

Last year they submitted about 5,000 pieces of feedback. Ninety-two percent of them are responded to within 24 hours. So it's not always, "yes, we'll do it," but it's, "Hey, great idea, Jeff, that suggestion on CRM is awesome. We're actually going to have the CRM hood opened in a couple of weeks. We're going to slide that in to one of the improvements. We'll get it done."

Or it might be just, "yeah, Jeff, I understand why you might want that but it's too expensive and we don't see the applicability of where other folks would use it, so we're probably not going to do that one."

And then there's just engagement. "Well, tell us a little bit more. What are you trying to do? Oh, You want to do that? Oh, you weren't aware we have a whole other system that does that."

And by the way, if they don't hear back within 24 hours, every morning at eight o'clock on the nose, about 200 of us could get an email. And it's all the feedback that was submitted yesterday, who submitted it, what they said, who claimed it, what they said. And if it's not responded to, it's at the bottom in red.

And then, you know, there's a lot of peer pressure: 'Why wasn't mine responded to?' And there's usually a good reason and it gets closed up by the end of the day. But you don't want to be in red.

We've all sent emails to companies, we've all left voicemails, and we feel like it goes to a black hole. There is no black hole at Commonwealth. You may not get a yes. You always get a response. You always are heard. You feel heard.

It's usually just a tagline. At Commonwealth, 'it's a firm for advisors by advisors' [is] not a tagline. We live and breathe it every day.

So when you ask what is the single biggest contributor [to the J.D. Power honors], I think that's it. It's the level of engagement. [The advisors] really feel part of what's going on here and, and they get to direct it or help direct it.

Apologies for the long answer to your question.

[Also a factor is] the technology [and] our partnership with [tech firm] Advisor360°. They were born out of Commonwealth, so [it's] a tech company that was born out of a broker-dealer/investment advisor, rather than coming the other way, just software. They understand they were advisor-facing people before they were technology people.

So I think that has helped, and we continue to add to the firm. We have over a thousand employees for 2000 or so advisors, and we don't self-clear. So we're either woefully inefficient or doing something really special. And I would argue that the advisor votes' sentiment and feedback says it's the latter.

So we've invested a lot. And whether it's marketing in the brand studio, the things we're doing in the high-net-worth space, it's our entrepreneurial capital program where we invest in our advisors' practices and help. Then with succession and financing the next generation. So it's not one thing. It's a mindset of continuous improvement added into that engagement part.

What drove Commonwealth's 2022 recruiting success, with 270 financial advisors joining with $11.24 billion? The firm now has about 2,100 advisors managing $243 billion in assets, right?

As I think you're alluding to, we had a record year … We've been out in the marketplace. We've been more aggressive with the way we're marketing, the way we manage our marketing funnel.

They wanted some liquidity options and their other firm couldn't satisfy those options. Or, if they could, they came with incredibly onerous restrictions. And ours don't; they're pretty free form.

We make decisions really quickly. We're a small, flat organization. So an advisor needs capital. Those decisions are made in hours or days rather than weeks and advisors had the ability to buy back their capital.

It's just how we operate. It's a flat advisor-centric organization, and our marketing team being much more proactive than they had in prior years.

I'm more concerned with the quality of the advisors than the number of advisors [we have]. I don't need to show the street that I'm growing a certain number of advisors.

We are still very selective and we only want the best advisors.

 How would you describe your typical Commonwealth advisor?

[Commonwealth is] an independent firm. So by definition there is no typical advisor … [but] they're predominantly planning-oriented and they're fee-based. Ninety percent of our current flow now goes into our fee-based [model]. So Commonwealth is much more a national RIA than it is a broker-dealer.

But it's important for us to have the broker-dealer as we're recruiting people, to give them a soft landing. We've had about 200, and I think we're approaching 250 advisors who have given up their FINRA license. So not only does the business flow resembles a national RIA; even the makeup of the advisors, they're migrating away from transaction-oriented business for fee-based.

It'd be probably cost effective for us just to be an RIA and not a BD operationally, because that's the vast majority of business.

Who are Commonwealth's key rivals?

Well, there's a lot of good firms up there, and I tend to focus more on what I'm doing and being the best that I can be, rather than focus on what other folks are doing.

But I'll answer your question sideways. It's not so much just the traditional independent broker-dealers. It's RIAs, it's rollup firms, it's custodians, it's technology platforms. It's sort of a multidimensional playing field now. You don't have just your traditional competitors. You're competing with a wide spectrum of people for service, for technology, for products, financially. It's just all over the map. Right? But I can only control what we do and we try and be the best that we can do.

Can you talk about Commonwealth's identity in 2023? How would you define your company? Are you chiefly an RIA, BD or boutique wealth firm? Or are you all of the above?

… [If] you look at the attributes of Commonwealth, it's technology, it's practice management, it's our wealth management, our advanced planning team.

It's just incredibly robust. Our retirement plan services team [and] all of these specific teams that resonate with different segments … So the people who are really focused on tech are going to be happy. They're going to get great options here if you're focused on retirement plans.

The wealth management team, the work they're doing in the high-net-worth space, and the advanced planning, helping them with complex cases. So you have just this plethora of support.

How does this identity differ from a year or so ago, and what will it look like about 12-18 months from now?

… We're trying to do a better job looking at the different segments of our advisors and making sure we're catering to their needs. We've got our core advisors, they may be solos or leads, but we've had a lot of growth in the ensembles and the enterprises and we have added more services to try and help them run what [they] are becoming.

And I think you're just going to see us maturing in that area …. [I] think we're going be offering more services and being more proactive on helping advisors get better. 

What would you say are the top industry changes and challenges, and what they represent for the marketplace Commonwealth competes in?

The two big ones: The regulatory environment is very challenging …. We're spending a lot of money. We make sure we're compliant. But the resources that have to go into it, it takes away. It's time. It's money.

The other one is technology. It's just we are really good there, but it's constantly evolving. The advisors want the very, very best in all categories. So making sure we're up to speed there is super important.

We do most of it with our sister company Advisor360°. It was terrific. But we're also adding in some third parties as well, which is consistent with the firm that's trending to be more of an RIA.

What keeps you up at night in mid-July 2023?

Right now, pitching, pitching, particularly the Red Sox bullpen…. You can never have enough pitching.

No, seriously, I sleep pretty well. There's always a plethora of things that could go wrong. But I guess if I were to give you a business answer, and I wouldn't say it keeps me up at night, but where's my particular focus? It's on making sure we can be as great as we could be.

Wayne Bloom, CEO of Commonwealth Financial Network.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center