Annuities are a viable retirement planning vehicle for many clients. They offer tax deferral during the accumulation phase and the possibility of guaranteed lifetime income.
They also have a tax impact when distributions start. Like most aspects of retirement planning, and with most retirement planning vehicles, tax planning is an integral part of the process of using annuities.
Here are some of the key tax planning issues tied to annuities to consider when determining whether an annuity is the right choice for a portion of your client's retirement savings.
Qualified vs. Nonqualified Annuities
When many clients and advisors think of annuities, they think of nonqualified annuities that are held outside of a retirement plan like a 401(k), IRA or 403(b) plan. However, qualified annuities are also an option in some cases for clients.
The taxation of qualified annuities will be in line with the tax rules pertaining to the type of retirement plan or account in which they are held. This is the same with other assets such as mutual funds and ETFs. Qualified annuities can be held in both traditional and Roth accounts.
Tax Benefits of Nonqualified Annuities
Nonqualified annuities offer a way for clients to invest and accumulate retirement savings that can grow tax-deferred. While contributions are made with after-tax premiums, the premium dollars grow inside the annuity with no tax impact until they are withdrawn either as a lump sum or via annuitization.
For clients who may have maxed out their 401(k) and IRA contributions, an annuity can offer another source of tax-deferred growth of their contributions for retirement. For clients who may be a bit behind in their retirement savings, an annuity can be another addition to their retirement savings with the benefit of tax-deferred growth.
Tax Issues to Watch
There are a number of tax issues connected with nonqualified annuities to keep in mind.
Early Withdrawals and Contract Surrender
You might encounter this issue in a couple of ways. First, it's not uncommon to take on a new client and review their portfolio only to decide that changes are needed. One such change could surround an annuity they were placed in by a former advisor.
Perhaps the contract expenses are too high, or it just isn't a good fit in your client's overall retirement planning.
Surrendering the contract will result in a penalty, if they are within the surrender period, and income taxes if they are under age 59.5. The entire amount of interest included in the contract value will be subject to taxes.
If there are no surrender charges, a better solution for your client might involve looking for a more suitable annuity contract and doing a 1035 exchange into the new contract. This will avoid the taxes and penalties.
While an annuity may or may not be the ideal solution for your client, avoiding the taxes and surrender charges preserves those funds for retirement. If the contract has a surrender charge, you will have to weigh whether to wait until the surrender period is over, or whether your client is better off "eating" this charge and doing an exchange into another annuity contract.
Last-In, First-Out Taxation
Any lump-sum withdrawal from a nonqualified annuity will be taxed on a last-in, first-out basis. In other words, it will be assumed that the first money withdrawn consists of gains inside the contract. Once the gains are totally withdrawn, subsequent withdrawals will consist of the basis in the contract.
A withdrawal of the entire contract amount will be taxed to the extent of the gains withdrawn. The gains will be taxed as ordinary income, much like a withdrawal from a traditional IRA or 401(k).
Annuitization and the Exclusion Ratio
Payments from a nonqualified annuity will be taxed based on the contract's exclusion ratio. The exclusion ratio states what percentage of each payment is considered gain and subject to tax.
The contract owner's life expectancy is a major factor here. If they outlive the expected annuitization period, the entire payment could become taxable as gains inside the contract.
Types of Annuities
The tax element of the exclusion ratio needs to be taken into account in deciding when to annuitize and in determining what type of annuity product to suggest for your clients.