Their Reasons:
Bloink: The current system does little more than pad the pockets of the wealthiest American business owners. We should reform the current Section 199A deduction rules to benefit the taxpayers it was intended to benefit — small-business owners who aren't raking in millions of dollars in profits each year. Changing the law to eliminate some of the complexities that also make it difficult for small business owners to know whether they're getting it right is also a step in the right direction.
Byrnes: These proposed reforms will never become law. The Section 199A deduction is designed to reduce some of the disparity in the tax treatment of a corporation versus the tax treatment of a pass-through entity. It isn't meant to provide a benefit only for small business owners, but to offer a benefit for all business owners who organize as pass-through entities.
Bloink: The QBI deduction gives the richest Americans yet another tax benefit. We have to be taking steps to ensure that all Americans pay their fair share. That includes wealthy taxpayers who can afford to run their income through a pass-through entity.
Byrnes: Putting an income cap on the amount of the pass-through deduction would only give business owners a perverse incentive to adopt business structures based on issues that may not be in the businesses' best interest. Democrats who think we're going to raise revenue by capping the 199A deduction are kidding themselves. Larger pass-through businesses will simply organize as traditional corporations and take advantage of the reduced corporate rates.
Bloink: The limits and phaseouts that currently apply in the 199A deduction context are overly complex and make it extremely difficult for taxpayers to calculate their deduction. Simply capping the deduction at a round number would both simplify the tax code and ensure that the deduction is geared toward providing the greatest benefits to the small businesses that it was designed to help.
Byrnes: I'm all in favor of simplifying the tax code. This is not the way to simplify 199A. These proposals would have one impact: They would give the largest pass-through entities an incentive to organize as C corporations, which may not always be the smartest option. Business owners should be incentivized to opt for the business structure that best meets the needs of the business — not the structure that simply gives them the lowest tax rate.
- Learn more with Tax Facts, the go-to resource that answers critical tax questions with the latest tax developments. Online subscribers get access to exclusive e-newsletters.
- Discover more resources on finance and taxes on the NU Resource Center.
- Follow Tax Facts on LinkedIn and join the conversation on financial planning and targeted tax topics.
- Get 10% off any Tax Facts product just for being a ThinkAdvisor reader! Complete the free trial form or call 859-692-2205 to learn more or get started today.
Bloink 
Byrnes 
