This Type of Portfolio Offers Best Odds of Success, According to Vanguard

Analysis January 06, 2023 at 02:57 PM
Share & Print

The drubbing that the traditional 60% stock, 40% bond allocation took in 2022 doesn't mean investors should abandon a balanced portfolio strategy, Vanguard analysts suggested recently.

"A balanced portfolio still offers the best chance of success," Roger Aliaga-Diaz, portfolio construction head for the mutual fund giant, and his team said in a recent note.

Notable in last year's global sell-off in stocks and bonds "was the degree to which both fell together," Aliaga-Diaz wrote. The two asset classes' long-standing negative correlation, in which returns moved in opposite directions, gave way in 2022 as stocks and bonds both sold off sharply.

This breakdown "was disconcerting for many investors and led some to question whether the 60% stock/40% bond portfolio still had merit as an investment tool," Aliaga-Diaz wrote. Longer term, however, the data support balanced portfolios, he suggested.

Rising equity valuations in 2021 pushed realized returns on the 60/40 portfolio well above Vanguard's forecasted range from 10 years earlier, while large losses in both equity and fixed income over the last 12 months brought those returns more in line with the firm's long-term view.

"Our research finds that correlations can move aggressively over shorter investment horizons but that it would take long periods of consistently high inflation for long-term correlation measures — those that more meaningfully affect portfolio outcomes — to turn positive," the report said.

Vanguard's long-term outlook for global stocks and bonds has now reversed its downward trend, with the higher return forecast largely driven by asset price declines that resulted from central bankers' interest rate increases, according to the note.

"The policy response to higher and more persistent inflation and the subsequent repricing of risk in global capital markets has led to a dramatic shift in our time-varying asset allocation (TVAA) outlook," the firm noted.

The TVAA looks to harvest the risk premiums for which the firm thinks there is modest return predictability.

Vanguard's optimal TVAA portfolio, based on the firm's current outlook, calls for a 50/50 stock and bond split, and favors bonds and emerging markets, according to the note.

While the benchmark 60/40 portfolio comprises 36% U.S. equities, 24% international stocks, 28% U.S. bonds and 12% international bonds, Vanguard's TVAA framework suggests 30% U.S. stocks, 20% international (divided equally between developed and emerging markets), 22% international bonds and 27% U.S. fixed income (mostly in U.S. intermediate credit bonds).

The TVAA portfolio should see lower volatility while producing expected returns similar to those of the 60/40 benchmark, according to Vanguard. It targets the same risk profile as the traditional benchmark portfolio, with the flexibility to deviate from the benchmark based on Vanguard's projected outlook, the firm said in its 2023 outlook.

The global interest rate tightening cycle in 2022 raised Vanguard's expected bond return forecasts by more than the equity market sell-off has raised expected equity returns, the firm noted.

Image: Adobe

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center