Source: Morningstar
Moving a step beyond grading a company for its carbon footprint, Morningstar announced a new tool on Tuesday to assess the carbon risk of a mutual fund portfolio. Carbon risk, or transition risk, is different than carbon footprinting, which basically is the physical measure of the amount of carbon a company produces. Carbon or transition risk "addresses how vulnerable a company is financially to the transition away from a fossil-fuel-based economy to a lower-carbon economy," said Jon Hale, Morningstar director of sustainable investing research.
Portfolios that have a low exposure to carbon risk and low levels of fossil-fuel exposure will receive Morningstar's Low Carbon Designation, a badge so to speak, so investors can quickly identify the funds. The measurement already is live on the Morningstar website.
Morningstar already included carbon footprint designations in its funds, but then Sustainalytics, the company it worked with, suggested an advanced way to measure funds beyond just the carbon footprint. Carbon footprinting "doesn't tell how much more value is at risk for a company with a high carbon footprint," and Sustainalytics said it was working on a new level of risk, Hale told ThinkAdvisor. "It's an advance on carbon footprinting."
"It's interesting to contrast [transition risk] with physical risk, which is much more idiosyncratic," Hale said. "Virtually any public company could have some exposure to climate change through physical risks they might face; it's almost more about the impact climate change has on specific aspects of their business. Those are things like, where do they do their business, such as in vulnerable areas that are subject to huge weather events, or episodic events, that a catastrophic, or ongoing, like rising sea levels. Or if you're in the insurance industry, are you insuring areas like that?"
He notes one company that mines salt for de-icing was concerned about the volatility of winter weather. "They can't predict as well [now] from one season to the next on the demand for their product; those are all physical risks."
However, says Hale, transition risks take into account the "financial materiality" of a company's carbon-risk exposure, or its actions and strategy to manage such risk.
