The U.S. is exceptional, and therefore an outlier in lots of international comparisons. Our incomes are high and our taxes are low, which is good. But our health care bills are astronomical and our infant mortality rate is awfully high, too (for a wealthy country), which is bad.
When it come to pensions and other retirement income, though, the U.S. is pretty average. That, at least, is my reading of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development's biennial "Pensions at a Glance" report, which came out Tuesday. "Pensions at a Glance" is a terribly misleading name for a document that fills 167 densely packed pages, and you may interpret the scads of data in it differently. But I at least have backup from the 2017 Melbourne Mercer Global Pension Index, which was released in October and has a couple of handy rankings graphics that can in fact be perused at a glance and put the U.S. right around the middle of the 30 countries rated: just behind the U.K. and France, just ahead of Malaysia and Poland.
What's curious about the U.S. retirement system, though, is that on average it's actually well above the average for members of the OECD, the organization of the world's affluent democracies.
For example, when you throw together payments from Social Security, defined-benefit pensions, defined-contribution 401(k)s and individual retirement accounts, retirement income in the U.S. looks generous:
When you look at the amount of money set aside to fund these retirement commitments, the U.S. system also looks quite solid by international comparison (the countries in the two charts are a not-entirely-random assortment of major OECD economies):
Where the U.S. system doesn't look so good is in its inconsistency. Americans' retirement situations vary dramatically depending on where they work, which generation they belong to, how good they've been about contributing to their 401(k)s, what they've chosen to invest that money in, and how they've chosen to withdraw it. Only 40.8 percent of the U.S. working-age population is covered by voluntary workplace pension or retirement-savings plans, according to the OECD. Another 19.3 percent have voluntary personal retirement accounts, but there's overlap between the two groups. The mandatory pension plan, Social Security, replaces a relatively low percentage of earnings (38.3 percent for those with average incomes, compared with an OECD average of 52.9 percent). And while this country's remaining defined-benefit pension plans are as a rule pretty generous, they are also as a rule underfunded, with an average funding ratio of 67.5 percent, compared with 88.7 percent in the U.K., 95 percent in Canada and 102.2 percent in the Netherlands.
