(Bloomberg) – When Donald Trump first rolled out his tax plan last October, it contained a major boon for the middle-class, a near quadrupling of the standard income-tax deduction, to $25,000 for individuals and $50,000 for couples filing jointly.
But when Trump updated his plan with an eye toward controlling its costs on Monday, he didn't mention the standard deduction at all — calling into question just how much benefit his plan has for lower- and middle-class taxpayers.
In its original form, the Republican presidential nominee's plan was set to exempt about 70 million lower-income Americans from paying any taxes at all and offer cuts to middle-income taxpayers, who are most likely to use the standard deduction. When that provision didn't make it into Trump's speech on economic policy Monday, observers were left to wonder just how much his revamped proposals will benefit lower- and middle-income Americans.
One of the "big question marks" in Trump's speech to the Detroit Economic Club was "what is he doing with the standard deduction," said Kyle Pomerleau, director of federal projects at the conservative-leaning Tax Foundation in Washington. "That was one of the biggest pieces in his original plan. If he backs away from it, it will significantly reduce the benefits to the middle class."
Zero rate
The standard deduction allows taxpayers to reduce their taxable income without itemizing expenditures, such as charitable donations or mortgage-interest payments. Because it's used most frequently by earners at the lower end of the wage scale, a large increase helps low- and middle-income people save on their taxes.
"No one will gain more from these proposals than low-and-middle income Americans," Trump said Monday of his tax plans. He added that "for many American workers, their tax rate will be zero." But he provided no detail on his new plans for the standard deduction, and his original proposal has been removed from his campaign website.
"We haven't settled on what it's going to be," economist Stephen Moore, who is advising the Trump campaign on tax policy, said after the speech. "It's going to be big enough so that most people won't have to itemize."
Related: Donald Trump, your 401(k) adviser
Trimming cost
Moore and economist Lawrence Kudlow have been working with the Trump campaign to try to lower the cost of his original tax proposal, which contained across-the-board rate cuts for individuals, a major cut in the corporate tax rate and a new business-income tax rate that would benefit both small businesses and billionaires. It's estimated cost: $10 trillion over 10 years.
Trump's new plan would provide more modest cuts in individual tax rates. It sets up three rates: 12 percent, 25 percent and 33 percent, which would replace the current seven rates, which top out at 39.6 percent. (He'd originally proposed lower rates of 10 percent, 20 percent and 25 percent.)
Combined with policies that would roll back business regulation and stimulate growth in the domestic energy industry, Trump's plans would create enough economic growth to cut the 10-year revenue cost to $2 trillion or less, Moore said.
Child-care deduction
One new provision in Trump's plan — a proposal that parents be allowed "to fully deduct the average cost of child-care spending from their taxes" — may provide much more benefit to taxpayers in the upper-middle class. Details of the plan are sketchy so far, but workers whose incomes are so low that they owe no taxes might not be able to take advantage of the deduction, while those with higher incomes could.
"Trump has moved away from his original plan of benefits to the middle class," said Martin Sullivan, the chief economist at Tax Analysts, a widely-read trade publication.
