Can professional golf help explain what is now happening with the stock market? I think that it can, because it offers a clue about an important source of this month's market volatility: human psychology.
The best golfers make par on most holes. They also have plenty of chances to make a welcome birdie (one under par) or to avoid a dreaded bogey (one over par). To do either, they have to sink a putt.
A stroke is a stroke, so you might think that whether a pro makes a putt can't possibly depend on whether the result would be making a birdie or avoiding a bogey. But you'd be wrong.
A study of over 1.6 million putts shows that professional golfers are significantly more likely to succeed in sinking a par putt than a birdie putt of equal distance and difficulty. Remarkable but true: If the average top golfer putted as well for birdie as he puts for par, he would make an additional $1.2 million a year.
Why do golfers do so much better when they are putting for par? The best explanation, coming from behavioral science, is that most people are "loss averse," meaning that they dislike losses a lot more than they like equivalent gains.
A loss from the status quo is very painful, and so people will do a lot to avoid it. A gain is good, but it isn't nearly as good as a loss is bad. Like the rest of us, professional golfers are affected by what John Maynard Keynes called "animal spirits": the feelings of the primitive creatures who lie within us. Hating the prospect of losses, golfers focus intensely on avoiding those bogeys, and often succeed.
Which brings us to the stock market. Of course it's true that the recent volatility, and the sharp declines, have a lot to do with real-world events, including slower growth in China and rapidly falling oil prices. But the fundamentals remain pretty solid, and the ultimate effects of such factors are at least partly a product of psychology.