The Low-Growth World Ahead: Vanguard’s Chief Economist

September 30, 2015 at 08:08 PM
Share & Print

Slow global growth will be "the defining trend of our lifetime," says Joe Davis, Vanguard's chief economist and head of the firm's investment strategy group. In the first keynote address at this week's Morningstar ETF conference being held in Chicago, Davis explained that the compounded annual rate for global growth is projected to be just 2% over the next 50 years, almost half the 3.8% rate of the past 50 years.

For investors, that means much more modest gains than in the past, or more specifically 3% to 6% annual gains in a portfolio split 60/40 stocks vs. bonds compared with 7.3% in 2014, 9.8% over the past 30 years and 8.7% since 1926, says Davis.

The biggest determinants of future global growth are the U.S. and China – they're the world's two largest economies, and they're headed in opposite directions, says Davis. The U.S. economy is growing while China's economy is slowing, dragging down emerging markets with it.

China is the biggest "tail risk" for the global economy, says Davis. 'If China experiences a recession and growth contracts [further], that would lead to a global recession."

China's current growth rate is well below the 7% the government says it is, closer to 5%, says Davis. "For the next decade 5% is not the floor but the ceiling for China's GDP growth," says Davis.  He blames China's real estate slump, not its very volatile stock market, for the deceleration.

Real estate construction is 10% of China's economy – double the ratio in the U.S. in 2007, when its housing market collapsed, and housing accounts for about 43% of Chinese household wealth compared with 23% in the U.S. in 2007, says Davis. On the flip side, mortgage debt is just 16% of China's GDP compared with 76% of U.S. GDP at the height of the housing crisis.

Another risk in China, says Davis, is the large number of state-owned enterprises, many with negative cash flow, and of companies that combine state and private ownership where the state is largely in charge. "The state has to exert less control over allocation of capital," Davis says.

The slowdown in China is depressing emerging market economies, which export commodities to the Asian giant. But emerging markets are also dragging each other down. "Despite a 35% drop in the value of their currencies, these economies haven't seen much of a rebound in trade because their trading partners are other emerging markets, not just China," says Davis. "Emerging markets need a new business model."

They also need to reduce debt, says Davis, explaining that private debt in emerging markets has soared to $32 trillion from $11 trillion in 2007. Davis gives 20% to 25% odds that emerging markets will fall into recession during the next few years, creating, with China, a "deflationary overhang" for the larger global economy.

Despite those concerns, Davis expects the U.S. economy will remain resilient and strong enough to withstand some monetary tightening. He expects a "modest reversal of accommodative" monetary policy by the Fed.

More specifically he expects the Fed won't raise rates more than 1% in the next tightening cycle, which he terms a "dovish tightening. "It doesn't matter if the Fed hikes in December or January," says Davis. "What's important is not whether Fed starts [tightening] but where it stops."

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center