Everybody Knows

January 03, 2012 at 07:00 PM
Share & Print

The town where my grandparents lived was largely settled by Irish immigrants, and to this day, people there still speak with a hint of an Irish lilt. One day, we encountered a drunk man on the sidewalk, of whom my disapproving Nana said, "Not every Irish here is a drunk, Billy, but all of the drunks are Irish." Being Irish herself, she said it with a kind of resigned sadness, that things like this leads one to believe that "everybody knows" something about another group of people. Everybody knows Irish are drunks. Everybody knows African Americans are criminals. Everybody knows Muslims are terrorists. And on and on it goes.

The weekend before this issue went to press, a fellow named Jules Manson — previously known best for a failed campaign for a seat on the Carson, California city council — landed himself in hot water with a racist Facebook rant that called for the assassination of President Obama. The post was taken down within an hour, but by then it was too late. Screen captures of the comment went viral and flew all over the internet, drawing no small amount of criticism.

Since Manson has been a vocal supporter of both Ron Paul and the Tea Party, it is being widely assumed by his detractors that Manson's own racism reflects what Paul and the Tea Party also feel. This would not be the first time the Tea Party has had to deflect insinuations of racism, which is unfair, since you cannot characterize an entire group of people based on the actions of just one of them.

And yet, I am reminded me of an episode in college, when my fraternity was voting on who should be extended an offer of membership. There were some ardent racists in my house, and one year, an African American student came up for bid. When we voted on it, the usual suspects blackballed him. They gave no reason, nor were they required to. Our chapter president, clearly angered, immediately brought the same student up for bid again. The rest of the room seconded the bid, and the usual suspects immediately took offense. How dare we assume that their reason for blackballing this kid was not valid? Well, we dared because these guys had well-documented histories of racism, and the fraternity's procedural rules were not meant to justify that kind of behavior. Ultimately, the kid who got blackballed never did get an invite to join the fraternity. It was an ugly scene.

The Tea Party has become just powerful enough to keep the GOP off-balance and to tinge national politics with a suspicion that something uglier is at play than mere opposition to Obama's politics. (Everybody knows Obama is a secret Muslim. Everybody knows Obama is not really an American.) As we begin a year sure to be consumed with nonstop discussion over our next presidential election, I would hope that our motivations for supporting one candidate over another is derived from a careful consideration of political positions and leadership qualities, and nothing more. We tell ourselves this is how we vote. It would be great if everybody knows it, too.

Bill Coffin
Editor in Chief

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center