Why Investors are Usually Wrong

Commentary September 30, 2009 at 08:00 PM
Share & Print

What will the market do next?

There are many indicators, and about as many interpretations of those indicators, investors use in an attempt to predict the market's next move. While some, if applied correctly, have a respectable track record, few indicators are as reliable as investor sentiment.

The irony behind this trusty gauge is that it fools investors into buying or selling at just about the worst time. Since investor sentiment surveys reflect the mood of the very investors who are trying to be a step ahead, it is a contrarian indicator. Why? Because market participants become more optimistic as stock prices rise and more pessimistic as stock prices decline. That's why market tops are accompanied by some degree of euphoria over stocks while market bottoms coincide with a doomsday-like atmosphere.

This interesting phenomenon is easily explained. Extreme bullishness becomes a problem for the bulls as an extended run for stocks increases the base of stock owners. At a market top, people wanting to own stocks will have converted from wanna-be buyers to owners. At that point, the pipeline of new buyers has dried up to a point where there's simply not enough buying volume to drive up prices any further.

This is compounded by the fact that owners are reduced to either holding or selling, neither of which can propel prices. As the base of stock owners has become unproportionally high, the cycle reverses. Inevitably some owners give in and start selling. As prices start to decline, more stocks are being sold and selling becomes the new trend. The unusual high level of stock ownership provides a consistent flow of stocks being put up for sale, resulting in rapidly declining prices.

Based on investor sentiment and other indicators, the ETF Profit Strategy Newsletter has given a sell signal on January 2, 2009, with the Dow Jones sitting at 9,000. This sell signal was based on elevated optimism. The extreme levels of pessimism seen a few months later however, served as foundation for the March 2nd buy recommendation.

Much has happened since the market bottomed in March. Stocks have rallied some 50%, and true to form, investors have become more optimistic about stocks. In fact, recent readings clocked in at levels of bullishness not seen since the 2007 all-time market top … and we know what happened then.

Additionally, the Volatility Index, also called VIX or Fear Index, has fallen below 23 for the first time in over a year which reflects the complacent attitude of investors. Complacent investors are always in for a bad surprise.

Based on those and many other indicators, it seems like the market has reached, or is encroaching upon, a major turning point. The October issue of the ETF Profit Strategy Newsletter includes a big picture analysis of the market's place in history along with target levels for the end of this rally and the ultimate market bottom.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center