House Votes Continue Pension Bill Battle

July 31, 2006 at 05:26 AM
Share & Print

The House passed a stripped-down pension bill Friday and an estate tax bill Saturday.

Lawmakers voted 279-131 to pass the pension bill, H.R. 4., which is based mainly on the proposed text of a conference report now being developed by the House-Senate pension bill conference committee. One major difference is that H.R. 4 excludes "extender" provisions that would extend several popular expiring tax cuts, such as the research and development tax credit.

Members of the House later voted 230-180 to pass the estate tax bill, H.R. 5970. That bill, the "trifecta bill," would phase in a reduction in the estate tax; raise the federal minimum wage level to $7.25 over several years; provide funds to ensure that abandoned mines are safe; extend post-disaster tax incentives for New York and the Gulf Coast; and authorize issuance of bonds to finance rural development projects.

H.R. 5970 includes a number of tax provisions cut out of drafts of the conference report version of the pension bill.

Supporters of sharp estate tax cuts added the minimum wage provision and some other provisions that are popular with many Democrats in H.R. 5970 in an effort to put political pressure on Democrats who oppose sharp cuts in the estate tax.

Lobbyists and congressional staffers expect H.R. 5970 to head to the Senate first.

The first Senate hurdle for the trifecta bill will be a cloture vote on a motion to proceed to the bill, the lobbyists and congressional staffers say.

The votes on H.R. 4 and H.R. 5970 came after an intense week of negotiations on the pension measure and the estate tax issue.

All Republican House members of the pension conference committee failed to show up Thursday for a scheduled signing of a proposed pension bill package conference report. The proposed report included the pension reform plan and the so-called extender package.

Republican supporters of sharp cuts in the estate tax have been trying to use support for the extenders to win support for a pension package, and support of the pension package to win votes for sharp cuts in the estate tax.

An estate-tax reduction bill is supposed to come before the Senate this week.

Democrats are unlikely to accept that estate-tax reduction bill, observers say.

"At this moment, it would appear that Congress is likely to go home for the one-month summer recess without having accomplished pension reform or extending several expiring tax provisions," according to Michael Kerley, senior vice president of federal government relations at the National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors, Falls Church, Va.

"The Senate may take up the pension bill this week," Tin VandenBerg, of Washington Analysis, Washington, writes in a note to investors.

But VandenBerg predicts that the Senate pension bill will be "held hostage" to efforts to pass a measure that would include sharp cuts in the estate tax.

"In the event that the Senate is unable to pass pension reform [this] week, we expect the legislation will reemerge in September when Congress reconvenes," VandenBerg writes.

VandenBerg says he is skeptical about the prospects for the tax measure getting through the Senate.

Sen. Harry Reid, R-Nev., Senate minority leader, put out a statement criticizing efforts to "holding working Americans hostage" to efforts to pass "hundreds of billions in tax giveaways" for the wealthiest Americans.

"The Senate has rejected fiscally irresponsible estate tax giveaways before and will reject them again," Reid says in the statement. "Blackmailing working families will not change that outcome."

The estate tax provisions in H.R. 5970 would:

- Increase the estate and gift tax exemption amount through a phase-in to $5 million per person effective Jan. 1, 2015, and then index it for inflation.

- Reunify the estate, gift and generation skipping transfer taxes.

- Reduce estate and gift tax rates.

Specifically, estates valued at up to $25 million (indexed for inflation) would be subject to tax at the capital gains tax rate (currently 15%, set to increase to 20% in 2011 unless extended). Amounts in excess of $25 million (indexed for inflation) or more would be subject to a phased-in reduced rate of tax of 30%. The 30% tax rate is fully phased-in effective Jan. 1, 2015.

- Make portable the spousal estate and gift tax exclusion to allow married couples to take full advantage of the $5 million per person exemption amount (indexed for inflation) by carrying over any unused exemption to the surviving spouse, subject to the phase-in of the exemption amount.

Kerley says that to envision the true cost of the Republican estate tax package, including the indexing policies included in the legislation, if the phased-in system went into effect as of 2009 the cost of the package to federal revenues would be $700 billion to $800 billion over 10 years.

"This will siphon off tax revenue that might have been used for other worthwhile purposes, such as above-the-line tax deduction for long term care insurance, or disability income insurance or incentives for individuals and businesses to acquire health insurance," Kerley says.

"There is a lot of competition for the use of tax revenues that would produce benefits to a far greater number of people than this estate tax 'reform'," Kerley says.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center