Financial Products To Fund LTC

June 30, 2002 at 08:00 PM
Share & Print

The financial threat of long-term nursing care costs may be the most significant threat that your clients face. With costs between $50,000 to $100,000 per year for care and the complexity of federal entitlement programs, insurance solutions are becoming more attractive to clients and planners.

An uninsured long-term care stay can destroy your clients estate and rob them of their hope and dignity.

Before presenting long term care as a solution to your clients situation, it is extremely important to have a good understanding of many of the provisions found in a typical policy, and how those may differ among carriers.

"Traditional" long-term care insurance is health insurance designed to pay for nursing and nursing care-related expenses. This insurance generally reimburses a policyholder or a designated care provider for nursing care expenses. Modern policies will pay for services such as nursing facility care, home health care, assisted living facility care, adult day care as well as some benefits for hospice and respite care.

Within the universe of long-term care insurance there are indemnity plans and per-diem plans available on the market today. Indemnity plans will reimburse a policyholder for expenses within policy limits whereas a per-diem plan will pay a stated dollar amount per day regardless of actual expenses.

So, lets take a look at traditional long-term care policy provisions so that you might better understand the basic construction of these contracts. When recommending a contract to your clients it is crucial that you understand when, how much, and under what conditions your client will be paid.

This is not as simple as the old life insurance sale. If you do a poor job for your client he or she may ask you to visit them at the nursing home to explain to their children why the inheritance is going to the nursing home–even though you sold them a policy. You, as well as your clients will have to live with the results of a poor job.

Benefit Amounts. The policy benefit amount is the amount of money, expressed either on a daily or monthly basis, that is available to the insured. An example might be $150 per day or $4,000 per month. The benefit may be the same amount or may be different for home care than for in-facility care

Benefit Period. The benefit period is the period of time that the company will pay benefits under the contract.

Benefit periods are expressed in either days or years, such as 1,095 days or 3 years. The benefit period may either be the same or different for the various benefits such as 4 years for in-facility care and 2 years for home care.

Policy Maximum. The policy maximum is the amount of benefit that the company must pay on your behalf while you are on-claim. If, for example, the insured had a $100 per day policy with a 3 year benefit period, the policy maximum would be $109,500.

What if the insured only accessed $50 per day in benefits for home care for 3 years? The company would generally continue to pay benefits until it had exhausted the $109,500 policy maximum. Be very careful in reading this section of the policy because some companies treat this a little differently from others.

As with the benefit periods, there may be different pots of funds for both in-facility care and home care. A policy might have $109,500 available for in-facility care and $54,750 for home care. Most policies will offer a combined single limit for both. Again, a very important difference from one contract to another.

Elimination Period. The elimination period can be thought of as the deductible or waiting period. This is the period of time that the insured is otherwise eligible for benefits but has chosen to pay for his or her care.

This is a place where policies can vary greatly. You should really understand the contractual provisions pertaining to this benefit. The elimination period is a place where many policyholders exercise selective memory at claim time. They remember wanting to lower the premium, but not that they agreed to pay for the first 60 days of care.

Benefit Triggers. The policy benefit triggers are really the heart of a LTC policy. This single provision tells your client under what conditions he or she will receive benefits.

The three major triggers are activities of daily living (ADLs), cognitive impairment and, if you have a non-qualified policy, physical necessity.

A claim would be triggered by the insureds inability to perform two or three of the generally accepted activities of daily living: Bathing, Continence, Dressing, Eating, Toileting, and Transferring. Social workers and medical personnel have devised standardized tests to check each of these activities.

A cognitive impairment is a decrease or loss of mental capacity or onset of dementia. The most infamous example of a specific dementia is, of course, Alzheimers disease. Again, standardized tests have been devised to determine a condition and the severity.

Physical necessity, as a benefit trigger, might seem redundant. If someone is exhibiting ADL deficiencies or cognitive impairment, doesnt this indicate a physical necessity? Maybe in some cases and maybe not.

It is argued that although the standardized testing for ADL and cognitive impairments are pretty good, they may sometimes fail and leave no room for common sense. If someone is "almost" qualified for benefits under either of the other two triggers, the physical necessity clause may just push it over to the clients benefit. When in doubt, benefit the client.

Having defined the three basic benefit triggers, it is important to understand how they may differ from one carrier to the next. One policy might say that an insured is qualified for benefits if he or she requires "human assistance" in performing 2 or more ADLs. Look at the definition of human assistance. Does it say "substantial?" Does it say "stand-by" assistance is OK? Remember, the more strict the language, the lower the probability of a claim being paid.

One policy might require that a caregiver be required virtually at all times, while another might allow for instances of reminding or just having help available.

Also look to see if a policy differentiates benefit triggers between in-facility care and home care and assisted living care. Generally, a policy that carries one set of triggers for all benefits is better. It lets the client pick the level of care.

When comparing policies, take a look at the additional benefits and riders that may be available. Inflation protection, whether as a policy rider or addressed in other ways, is critical.

Another important provision is the waiver of premium. One policy might waive premiums during a time when any claim is being paid while another policy might only waive premiums after 180 days and only if the insured is confined to a facility. Be very careful of this provision.

Premiums. Premiums are based on a variety of factors: Age, health, benefit amount, benefit period, and elimination period. The higher the benefit amount and period and the shorter the elimination period, the higher the premium. Age and health are a different story.

What I tell people about premiums and age is this: The insurance company is charging premiums against the possibility of your needing care before you die. They have a great deal of confidence as to what average mortality is. What they want to do is collect about the same amount of premium from you between now and the time you pass away to hedge their bet. Whether you start paying now and pay for 30 years or wait 20 more years and only pay for the last 10 years of your life, the total is about the same. Why not do it now while youre healthy and the premiums are more manageable? Premium tables and an actuarial chart will put this together for you.

Another important item when discussing premiums is if its guaranteed renewable but not non-cancelable. This means that the contract cannot be changed by the insurance company or canceled unless you fail to pay the premium.

Although the premiums cannot be changed on any single contract, premiums may be changed for an entire class of policy. It needs to be understood that this is health insurance and subject to changing health and morbidity claims.

Companies need to reserve the right to adjust premiums to meet their claims obligations. I expect to see more rate decreases in future years than increases.

Establishing A Benefit Amount. Establishing a benefit amount for long term care insurance will never be an exact science until our clients can tell us when and where they are going, what level of care they will need, how long they will need it, and what the daily cost of care will be. While these are all unknowns, we need to strike the fine balance between too little and too much insurance.

The formula I use works more easily for single people than couples but it should give you the idea. If a single client is lying in a nursing home bed, he or she is still receiving Social Security Benefits, their pension and any other passive incomes. These sources dont care where the beneficiary is.

If a facility bed costs $60,000 per year and the person has $30,000 of passive income, they will need $30,000 more to provide for their care. I would bump this up to at least $36,500 ($100/day) to get a jump on inflation. A little more budgeting work should be done in case there are other obligations that the person might have but this gives you the idea. With married couples you need to determine the amount or resources that the non-institutionalized spouse might need to live on and assume the balance can go to care. Again, some budgeting work will help your clients get closer to the right amount.

One of the wild cards in the formula is the daily cost of care. In New Hampshire, where I practice, it ranges from about $150 per day to over $260 per day for specialized facilities. Which one will your client end up in? Do a screening of care facilities in your state to see what the average costs might be. You might also find a substantial variation.

Inflation is another big wild card. When will your client need the care and what will it cost then? Medical inflation can run in double digits. A minimum of a 5% to 6% inflation (compounded) assumption should be made. Inflation can be handled by inflation riders or by increasing the initial amount of insurance (daily benefit). Run the numbers on a policy with the right base amount and an inflation rider. Then see what that premium would buy in initial benefit.

You might find that the increased initial benefit exceeds the ultimate benefit for the policy with the inflation rider. This gives the client a better initial benefit as well as providing for inflation for the same premium.

The last real opportunity for your plan design to fail is the benefit period. According to Health Care Financing Administration, the average nursing home stay is 2.8 years. This is up slightly from 2.5 years over the last few years. Keep in mind, however that for every person that needs care for only one day, someone else may need several years. These are averages, and should be treated as such.

But, rather than try to get someone to purchase a lifetime benefit (let them if they want to), why not suggest a 4- or 5-year benefit period? These beat the "average" and Medicaid has a 36-month look-back period (this may increase over the next few years). If a nursing care stay is truly going to go beyond 4 to 5 years, other planning methods can be employed.

This gives us a basic method of arriving at a benefit amount and benefit period. The other considerations such as riders and elimination period can be worked out between benefits and premiums.

Stephen N. Mathieu, CFP, CLU, is founder and president of Elder Planning Advisors of New Hampshire, Manchester, N.H. He may be reached via e-mail at smathieu

@elderplanningadvisors.com. This is an abridged version of a presentation he gave at the MDRT annual meeting in Nashville.


Reproduced from National Underwriter Life & Health/Financial Services Edition, July 1, 2002. Copyright 2002 by The National Underwriter Company in the serial publication. All rights reserved.Copyright in this article as an independent work may be held by the author.


NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center